i am 21 yrs old and i have the following trouble.......3 yrs abck i took kalimur 6x for inflammtion in my eyes ...this fortunately also affected my constipation problem my bowels would move regu laerly as long i took those pills ....i landed up taking kali mur 6x 4a period of three mths <it would affect only as long as i took the medicine>,,,,,,but during this period i developed tonsils hte book i was reffering to ....<twelve tissue remedy by borecke and dewey says that there is a proving of the 6 x
remedy causing tonsils >
after that i did treatment with 2 homeopaths but i would get only temporary relief and my tonsils wouls swell up on having anyhting cold ........i then took belladona on my own and devloped a small boil on my left tonsil
on getting a sore throat its my left side which is the worst affectd .....
since the past two yr im also experenciencing extremely dry skin i get up in the morning with the skin on my hands dry and stretched .....my nails also seem to be pitted and they split ......i went to a skin specilaist and he said they may be symtoms of hypothyroidsm and has asked me to geta test done....i also have very cold hands and feet
.......i m very fond of sweet things ...like choclates ,biscuits pastries etc
.......i have been reading homeopathy on my own .......and do have a little idea abt it
persoanlly i sometimes think i m arsenic alb because i m a little stingy at the same time i really admire beutiful expensive things and buy them ......i also change my doctor very often if i dont c a posive response ....but i dont sip water like arsenic alb ...i always gulp water down ,,,,<much like bryonia>
nor do i have any burning
anybody there could plz help me with my problem ....i would be glad to reply to any more questions

hello,
you already taken some medicines by yourself .by reading the materia medica the inexperienced feels ,the medicine are suitable to them and their symptoms are there .when reading another medicine the same will occur again .so now please stop your self medication and wait for some time wthout any medicinal effect . the present you are experiencing may be your mdisease plus the symptoms of medicine .so give some time to clear the action of medicine and consult a homoeopathic doctor for the remaining symptoms at that time
pannakkal

THIS IS NOT PROOVING SYMPTOMES, THIS IS SILICEASYMPTOMES, I SUGGEST ONE DOSE OF SILICEA X200, AND IF FEARING PROOVING SYMPTOMES, CLEAR THOSE AWAY WITH ONE DOSE CAMPHORA X30, WAIT THREE DAYS USE SILICEA.

------------------
Homeopat MNNH Geir E.T. Marcussen
email: getm@eunet.no
http://www.homeopati.no

thank u for replying ........this is in reply to GM .....well while taking homeopathic treatment from my homeopath he did give me silicea 200c for a period of 2 weeks but it dint affect me at all ...is silecia the only remedy for splitting nails ??
as far as my constipation problem is concerned i dont have a problem of hard stools i just dont get an urge to pass stools and thus i ve been taking laxatives since the past three yrs ..

Well, well, then you have a prooving from Silicea, bad homeopath, if homeopat at all!
Use camphora to antidote it, take no silicea.
You shall take hydrastis x200 one dose, as this is the remedy for damages after abuse of laxatives.
And your case should be retaken after a month, when symptomes of prooving and laxatives abuse are gone, only then will the thrue picture emerge, and correct remedie for you be chosen.
If hydrastis dont work,for the intestes/stool alternatives is nux v, and papaver somniferum.


------------------
Homeopat MNNH Geir E.T. Marcussen
email: getm@eunet.no
http://www.homeopati.no

thank u GM for all ure help ,
...i would take camphor 30x .....how many pills should i take and should i take it only once ....?
plz could u suggest me a good homeopathic doctor in bombay .....there are many here and i dont really know whose good ...i would like one who treats me constitutionally ....as i have already gone to two of them who have spent only about 15mins with me on the first
meeting .....which i dont think is enough ...
thank u once again ......

Camphor x30 once a day, three days max, should take care of the most.
I know no one in Bombay, But Gary do, so post a question about this in the discussion forum, he has answered some others on the same question, and you find some adresses there. If still no help, return to us, and well help you.

Hello GM,
you are seem to be prescribing antedote"camphor" ferquntly.Please tell me the logic behind it .
as far as my concern I am against it .camphora seems to antidote some veg. drugs I read .
I think no medicine can antidote another mdicine in its full extent as both are different with different property .
here you added one more remmedy to her already lot I think.
to eradicte the action of the previous remedies, the best method I think is to (1) wait until the action is gone and old symptoms appear
2.if is not gone fully ,take the present symptoms(disese symptom and drugs) in details and prescribe.
3.patient taken many remedies in many potencies and I think prescribing camphor 12x or 30 like that only add patient's misery .
panakkal

PANNAKAL:
HERE ARE ANSWERS TO YOUR QUESTIONS!

Hello GM,
you are seem to be prescribing antedote"camphor" ferquntly.Please tell me the logic behind it .
as far as my concern I am against it .camphora seems to antidote some veg. drugs I read .
ANSWER:
Read up some more, then you will find that Silicea is one remedy that is antidoted by camphora, Arsenicum another.

I think no medicine can antidote another mdicine in its full extent as both are different with different
property .
here you added one more remmedy to her already lot I think.
to eradicte the action of the previous remedies, the best method I think is to (1) wait until the action is
gone and old symptoms appear

ANSWER:
Here you contradict yourself at several points, if you think that no medicine can antidote to the full extent, i give you rigth in that, it is so with several, but not all, and you follow then organon, who plainly tells you to use the best antidote in every case, as you describe, but why cant you use a remedy who covers the most, in a low short acting potence , like camphora x30 who acts 12 houers, to take the top of the trouble, ( espcially since it is the best cover in this case, a better choice than ac fl) instead of waiting long ( some months/years maybe) with full symptomes, tell me why, lack of experience?! Waiting long, letting the patint have the prooving, is not allowed after organon!
Its after organon to chose appropriate remedy, wait until it is through working,, take a new analysis, prescribe after the present symptomes, and this you can do fast after camp, you then choose a new remedie, exactly what i have prescribed.


To wait,, when having medical symptomes, That is not allowed by organons laws.
And to wait til the patient is dead, is not adviseable, since the use of wrong remedies in highpotences, creates a uncurable medical disease at its worst, and a bearly managable casus at the middle, at the best it goes away by it self fast, not so in most cases, it goes on in months, or years, or not at all if not treated.

2.if is not gone fully ,take the present symptoms(disese symptom and drugs) in details and prescribe.

ANSWER: In this case the present symptomes was Siliceasymptomes, and i do not give Silicea for Silicea, except as a low x potence, as a antidote, if you have followed me, i do that to, i use appropriate remedies in each case, and not as you indicate, wildly, always from experience, not from delusions, but as a securety, because of use of other remedies, that camphora covers.
.
3.patient taken many remedies in many potencies and I think prescribing camphor 12x or 30 like that only
add patient's misery .
panakkal

ANSWER: I have never seen what you tell, when using x potences either, all what you apply of adding symptomes, goes for for the potences you use, namely C and above, that i have experienced to, so dont critizize me based on what you obviously dont know, as i saw on your prescription of graphites based on nothing, that was a far more serious fault than prescribing camphora low, when its appropriate.

And instead of critizizing me, why dont you ask the patient to report back, so all can see if your fears and thougths is becoming thrue, ore if i do my job, after all, who has got credit for giving correct help here?
Then jealosy and other negativities would easely be cleared off.
Its not my fault that none of you dont have my experience, and i do not tolerate to be critizied for that either, its your own responbinselty to get experience, not mine.

Ill excuse you, if your criticims is based upon a misinterpretion of my posting,or a bad language, then is this all nothing to bother each other about.
And i can take criticism, when its based on experience, and science, but not if its based on believes or fanatism, or other low qualities of human kind.

Similia similibus currentur.
Aude sapere.
GM

Hello,
for the answer in organon you should look the aph 92,and 93 .where it is clearly told how to deal with the situation .
if the disease chronic nature and ,the advice in the section is as above said by me .that is wait for some time ,until the symptoms are disappearing and take the whole picture and treat as new.if it is an acute case and dangerous (as per aph92)-most suitable remedy to cover that condition immediately .
the medicine kali mur ,that she is taken here for long time .and what about antidote of this . her dryness may possibly due to this .
don't take these things as critisism ,only accademic.and as far as experience is concerned I am not agreeing with your view either .
I still thik it is not necessory to advice camphor as antidote as you frequently prescribing.
every practisioners have their own views and according to their experience they act and every doctor want to cure or at least palliate their patient according the situation.
thak you for your information
pannakkal