Dear Hans
The research paper was done by Dr. Kumar........................
Not Who you call DuckQuack.
Here is his contact info if you want to know more about his documentation:


DR.DEVENDRA KUMAR.M muntadev2in@yahoo.co.in,V.B.Colony,Machilipatnam,Krishna dt,521002, Andhra pradesh, India

__________________
"Great ideas often recieve violent opposition from mediocre minds"...................Einstein

I know, Gina. I have been in communication (via hpathy forum) with Dr. Kumar.

The reference to DocQuack was a reply to muntadev2in, who commented on a discussion I had with someone with that username, also on hpathy.

DocQuack had another creative experiment: I HAVE PROOF HOMEOPATHY WORKS!!

As you can see from the address you gave, it seems that muntadev2in IS indeed Dr. Devendra Kumar. Thus, he is right here and can comment if he will.

Hans

__________________
<i>You have a right to your own opinion, but not to your own facts.</i>

Yes, unfortunately, the administrator of that forum (Manish Bhatia) has declared that opponents of homeopathy are not welcome:

A Notice for Skeptics and Trolls

Not only that, but I have, lately, been the target of some rather suppressive moderation action (critical posts deleted without comment). Of course, the people at hpathy are free to run their forum in any way they please, but as long as they choose to run it this way, it will be without me, a solution I assume they prefer.

Hans

__________________
<i>You have a right to your own opinion, but not to your own facts.</i>

Dear Hans
The scientific homeopathic forum has a seperate moderator (NOt dr. B) These are the forum rules as posted by the moderator: (go to site for full disclosure)
moderator’s note - REV 01/01/08

Effective immediately, the Scientific Research in Homeopathy discussion forum will operate under the following revised rules. .................................................. .................................................. ...............

This Said: You can contact Dr. Kumar in person via the link I posted You dont need Hpathy to do this Hans.Dr. Kumar has a Blog Where you can post coments
Same goes for DOC QUACK (Stan) you can contact him personally in his website........................

__________________
"Great ideas often recieve violent opposition from mediocre minds"...................Einstein

Dear Gina,

I'll not discuss the moderation of another forum here, except to note that I'm aware of who is moderating the hpathy science forum and hence also who has been responsible for the mentioned abusive moderation.

Dr. B has not moderated my posts. He just asked me (and other skeptics) to leave, using the term "these forums", so I assume he means the entire hpathy forum.

Whether he has the authority to do so or not, is not for me to judge.

Anyway, they all know where they can find me.

Hans

__________________
<i>You have a right to your own opinion, but not to your own facts.</i>

Dear Hans

muntadev2in ID is mine, Dr.Devendra Kumar MD(Homeo),

if you have any doubts more you can contact me as Gina had given my ID at muntadev2in@yahoo.co.in ,

or else

you can repeat this simple experiment.

It is not difficult for you.

If you could able to repeat the experiment as I explained in my blog, it needs to remove the name 'Homeopathy' from JAMES RANDE Million dollars Challange. Is it not?

Dr.Devendra Kumar

Dear Devendra Kumar,

I could try to repeat your experiment, yes. However, it would be difficult because your report is very unspecific. Also, as long as you seem to be unable, or unwilling, to explain how you got your results and what they signify, I don't really see why I should take the trouble.

I don't understand your comment about the James Randi Prize. Have you applied for it? As long as the challenge is running (it will be discontinued later this year), then by explicit declaration by Mr Randi, homeopathy is eligible for the challenge, so if you think you can prove anything you should consider applying. After all, a million USD is nice to have.

Do note, however, that I have no connection with the James Randi Educational Foundation, so you will have to contact them directly.

Best regards, Hans

__________________
<i>You have a right to your own opinion, but not to your own facts.</i>

Mr.Hans I have given the procedure I have followed, to Identify homeopathic medicines in my blog.

Identification of Homeopathic Medicines by Measuring Physiological Variability in Human Body Temp .

Since you are not from medical profession, you are unble to understand the biological phenomenon.

"You are not the right person to comment on Homeopathy"

Dr.Devendra kumar

Devendra Kumar, I'm a quality professional in the medical industry. If you can explain your results, I can understand them. That has nothing whatsoever to do with homeopathy. You are claiming that you measure something in a homeopathic remedy, with a piece of measuring equipment. That is exactly my speciality. I don't need to understand homeopathy for that.

Hans

__________________
<i>You have a right to your own opinion, but not to your own facts.</i>

Dear Hans you said that I have measured ----in Homeopathic remedy, it is not so, I have measured the effect of homeopathic medicine ie temperature variability in human body after giving homeopathic remedy at a specific time of the day. I have controlled the study with placebo. I have observed differece in temparature variability with placebo and medicine subjects.

As as a Homeopathic physician I know the importance of time of action of remedy, Bio rythms, geographical variability in action of remedy, dynamic action of remedy, potentisatin process, the concept of vital force.

With which I have framed ceratain principles upon which the action of homeopathic remedy depends.

Do you aware of it?

Having instrumental knowledge is not sufficient to understand the science of Homeoapathy. What you say?

Please go through my blog in full and comment.

Dr.Devendra Kumar.