Hi Group, ( i don't know if this if offtopic or not)

I had replied to a question in a share ur experience section of NDTV
site. A chest specialist has replied that homoeopathy has no cure and
that he has seen ppl suffer from homoeopathy and if there is give proof.
is what he says.

Plz go thorough this site

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/V...d=24&pollid=24


Section Tuberculosis Subject: Re:Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

Sent by Dr Anirban Biswas (NO) Thursday, March 09, 2006

Site : http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/readtop20.asp
or

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/V...d=24&pollid=24


I have 2 doughts

Was my first reply wrong? I had replied for that particular case?
Now what must i do? Ignore the question? If reply what to reply?

Dr.Nandana.T.Pai

Cut and past from the site

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/v...d=24&pollid=24
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

I noticed a soft growth in my lower neck region. It was diagnosed for
TB. There was no symptoms what so ever, no weightloss, no exersion etc.
Actually Im one of the fittest and active persons in my group. Im a
regular member of gymnasium. when it was diagnosed for TB of lymph
glands APPROXIMATELY an year back after tuberculin test as well as FNAC,
I took regular medication for about 10 months, but the glands seemed the
same. However, a later biopsy done also confirmed TB. The doctor
mentions that I need to take altered medcation for additional year
(which means two years of medication for infection of two lymph nodes!!)
I want to consult TB speciallist for my case. Im in Pune, INDIA and
would want to know any TB hospital/speciallist in Pune. Thanks a lot, Jyoti
- Sent by Sunitha (India) Tuesday, January 10, 2006

Reply | Back



Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

Sunitha, Homoeopathy is a system which is there even before the so
called Dots etc came into being. The success rate of homoepathy is 99%
especialy in TB. Most of the poineers of homoeopathy and even the
propogators of Homoeopathy in the early days where recovered from the
conditon even in the termanal stages when all the systems had told no
hope. Your case is very simple and can be treated in a matter of few
monts. So Plz see a good Homoeopathy in ur area. Dr.Nandana.T.Pai Kochi
Kerala
- Sent by Dr.Nandana.T.Pai (India) Wednesday, February 01, 2006

Reply | Back



Re:Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

that homeopathy can cure TB, it is your claim.Can you support it by
authentic scientific data?dont compare this nuisence system with
DOT.Being a chest physician I have very sad experience with patients of
TB who were treated with homeopathy initially.Belief is one
thing,science is another.DOT is made free by govt. of India free to
every TB patients.Any patient with TB, must access DOT, in nearby hospital.
- Sent by Dr Anirban Biswas (NO) Thursday, March 09, 2006


Reply | Back



For those who are not able to open the link.

Dr.Nandana.T.Pai

Hi Group, ( i don't know if this if offtopic or not)

This is a repost as i am not geting the answer for the question i asked.

I had replied to a question in a share ur experience section of NDTV
site. A chest specialist has replied that homoeopathy has no cure and
that he has seen ppl suffer from homoeopathy and if there is give proof.
is what he says.

Plz go thorough this site

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/V...d=24&pollid=24


Section Tuberculosis Subject: Re:Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

Sent by Dr Anirban Biswas (NO) Thursday, March 09, 2006

Site : http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/readtop20.asp
or

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/V...d=24&pollid=24


I have 2 Questions

Was my first reply wrong? I had replied for that particular case?
Now what must i do? Ignore the question? If reply what to reply?



Dr.Nandana.T.Pai

For those who are not able to open the link i am pasting it below

Cut and past from the site

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/v...d=24&pollid=24
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

I noticed a soft growth in my lower neck region. It was diagnosed for
TB. There was no symptoms what so ever, no weightloss, no exersion etc.
Actually Im one of the fittest and active persons in my group. Im a
regular member of gymnasium. when it was diagnosed for TB of lymph
glands APPROXIMATELY an year back after tuberculin test as well as FNAC,
I took regular medication for about 10 months, but the glands seemed the
same. However, a later biopsy done also confirmed TB. The doctor
mentions that I need to take altered medcation for additional year
(which means two years of medication for infection of two lymph nodes!!)
I want to consult TB speciallist for my case. Im in Pune, INDIA and
would want to know any TB hospital/speciallist in Pune. Thanks a lot, Jyoti
- Sent by Sunitha (India) Tuesday, January 10, 2006

Reply | Back



Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

Sunitha, Homoeopathy is a system which is there even before the so
called Dots etc came into being. The success rate of homoepathy is 99%
especialy in TB. Most of the poineers of homoeopathy and even the
propogators of Homoeopathy in the early days where recovered from the
conditon even in the termanal stages when all the systems had told no
hope. Your case is very simple and can be treated in a matter of few
monts. So Plz see a good Homoeopathy in ur area. Dr.Nandana.T.Pai Kochi
Kerala
- Sent by Dr.Nandana.T.Pai (India) Wednesday, February 01, 2006

Reply | Back



Re:Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

that homeopathy can cure TB, it is your claim.Can you support it by
authentic scientific data?dont compare this nuisence system with
DOT.Being a chest physician I have very sad experience with patients of
TB who were treated with homeopathy initially.Belief is one
thing,science is another.DOT is made free by govt. of India free to
every TB patients.Any patient with TB, must access DOT, in nearby hospital.
- Sent by Dr Anirban Biswas (NO) Thursday, March 09, 2006


Reply | Back

-----------

dear dr pai,

homeopathy is an advanced healing science and all of us have to practice high quality of homeopathy to counter the false propaganda of these allopaths and pharma companies. arguements will not help.

just minutes ago I was reading lachesis in clarke's and there I read about excpetions to the left to right rule: dr j. h clarke says - "Although lach. is a left-side medicine, it has a powerful action on the liver as well as the spleen. "Acute pain in liver extending towards stomach," though contrary to the general "left to right" direction, is characteristic, as I can testify. lach. is also one of the most prominent remedies in appendicitis."

allopathy is sure more easy and straight forward!

as far as your TB related query is concerned, direct dr anirban to dr prafull vijayakar's site and ask him to contact dr vijayakar for video proof, hospital papers and other investigation proof.
dr vijayakar's website is:
http://www.prafullvijayakar.com

there is not much info on website but dr anirban may put the cursor on -about dr vijayakar - click case studies - listed cured case no. 52 is that of niku minhas, hospital case of tubercular meningitis.

dr anirban may go through all the other cases listed here and ask himself whether homeopathy is really a nuisance!

dr anirban may also check the website of the faculty of homeopathy, UK, which gives training to allopaths in homeopathy.
http://www.trusthomeopathy.org/

I hope dr anirban biswas is able to broaden his understanding, reasoning, education and thought.

regards,
dr manish agarwala