dear david,
oops ! i am sorry !
i use the otherhealth.com forum and getting used to the threads system.
i just checked the other thread and found your replies there.
thanks a lot for the sincere replies.
thanks again -
best regards
manish agarwala

dear david little

you wrote to me :-

There are, however, a few cases that do better on the higher Cs. You shared
one where the LM did not do much and the 10M cured, didn't you? That was
one of those exceptions to the general rule. My only suggestion is when
your not satisfied with the LM - try the Cs.

yes, right.

as i learn the finer art of LMs (i first learnt to use LMs from dr dhananjoy roy of calcutta who was a colleague of dr harimohun chowdhury and i am still learning the finer aspects from you) i realise that i can do more with LMs than i previously thought.
i still feel frustrated at times and feel like going for a single dose 10M or straight away a CM but then i also remember and know how "dramatic" things are with high C's.

as far as difference in aggr due to dose vs aggr due to potency is concerned - i try to understand your comments by carefully subjecting myself to such situations. unless i know something experientially, i cannot perceive it in others.

i have proved many remedies on myself, trying to understand them and in the past (not too long ago !) when i was a kentian prescriber i have felt the aggr of high C's myself. both myself and my mat med teacher have done the madness of taking a CM on one day and regretting our decision the very nexy day !

i think hahnemann's advanced posology has a lot of scope to grow and do better.

i fully agree with what you say. one should be flexible.
but i do have a personal view. i admit that it is my personal view.
i feel that had hahnemann lived longer he may have refined the use of LMs and made less and less use of the C's.
at present i see the need of low C's (6, 12,30) for situations where LM 0/1 aggravates and also for the travel kits.

having said that, i do not mean that one should not have an open and flexible mind.

regards
manish