dear list
dr william earnest boyd discovered 11 remedy groups on the basis of emmanometric research.
this is given in page 448-453 of the book 'principles of prescribing' by
dr k n mathur. b jain.
i found a remedy called "mam" mentioned after scirr. in group no 11.
i did not find this "mam" listed in gr no 11, on a website, when i did a yahoo search.
can anyone confirm the exact contents of dr boyd's gr. no 11 ?
is there a remedy with abbreviation "mam" ?
best,
dr manish agarwala

Yahoo! India Matrimony: Find your life partneronline.

Dear Dr.

I am not sure what is going on here, however, on looking up eg., Scirrinhum
in Synthesis, which I agree is found on page 451 Mathur, included in Group
11, I discovered, that in Radar, it is considered to be in Group 5.

Someone has made an error.

I then went and checked which rems are included in Group 11 in the Family
Selection section of Radar and these are the rems I found

asafoetida
asarum Europaeum
calotropis gigantea
helonias dioica
paeonia officinalis
solanum nigrum
stillingia silvatica
thallium aceticum
thallium metallicum
thuja occidentalis

As you can see, this is a different list than those presented in Mathurs
book. Someone has made an error.
It is not for me to guess which one is in error - However, I believe that
Will Taylor has put the family module together, and he is very thorough and
I would not expect him to make an error such as this - but anything is
possible :-)

I realise this will only add to your query on the remedy <mam>, which must
be a typographical error.


Best

Robyn

dear robyn

i sure don't know - what is going on. i think scirrh ought to be in gr 11.

i did a yahoo search and i found a link:-
http://www.homoeopathyclinic.com/ar...em_Relation.pdf
this link must have taken input from mathur, as it appears, but the <mam> after scirr. is missing !

is <mam> a reference to 'mammary' - meaning scirrhinum(mammary) ?
the brackets may have been left out in the mathur b jain version.

i am not sure, but i think i did read in murphy (perhaps) that scirr. is from liver. clarke mentions scirr to be from scirrhous CA breast.

i was not sure about <mam> . now you have added to the mystery.
whic is the real boyd gr 11- radar(will taylor) or mathur ?
what about <mam> ?

manish

dear homeolist,

I am referring to my old thread on homeolist at otherhealth.com titled 'dr william boyd'. I have put all posts related to this topic under this thread.

is this some mistake / bug in radar ?

can anyone please forward this to archibel for a reply or clarification.

if someone here is a member of the radar discussion groups, he may be able to clear the picture.

dr manish agarwala