Hi everyone,

I have been told by my homeopath that everybody should go through a sulphur state at some point in his treatment.
I have read some sulphur descriptions, and I could not find myself in that at all! I have been treated with various remedies in my life; pulsatilla, natrum muriaticum, ignatia, silicea, lycopodium, which have definitely helped me. Homeopathy has been like a journey for me, moving me from one state to an other. But I have to say that I find it hard to believe I could go through a sulphur state at some point.

What are your views on that? If that is true why does everybody should go through a sulphur state at some point?
I would really love to hear your comments as I have had that on my mind for a while.

Thank you very much

Ren

PS: sorry for my english (my first language is french)

to Sulphur.

There are the characteristic states where one has hot feet in bed and a hot temper to match-- up and over quickly-- careless of appearance and untidy - early morning bowel movement etc etc.

BUT

There is the aspect that relates it to the Miasmatic spectrum . Here it is the fact that there are few who can not be favorably influenced by SOME potency of Sulphur.

The higher potencies of Sul tend to deal with the first paragraph.The lower potemcies operate on the miasmatic level. Alternation of Sul 3x and Nux Vom 3x can be used in the sycotic area for instance.

Thank you very much Passkey for your reply.
I am not sure I understand it fully though.
Do you mean that my homeopath was wrong, and therefore not everyone should go through a sulphur state at one point in his life?
I think what he meant was that a successfull treatment (chronic desease) should always end with sulphur. Do you agree with that?

thank you

Ren

is NO he is wrong

Dear Ren
I have never heard of this? Hmm.... wonder what your homeopath meant by this? Taking it for face value....my answer would be no.
Sometimes a homeopath will give sulph. in a difficult 'stuck case' to get the symptoms to move outward/forward. And then see what comes of the symptomology. Sulp. can be used for various 'acutes' so in this case the answer might be 'yes'..........puzzling remark.

Gina Tyler

__________________
"Great ideas often recieve violent opposition from mediocre minds"...................Einstein

Dear members
sulph cures sulph like diseases.

__________________
Hans Weitbrecht
Consultant Homeopath

Thank you all for your replies.
Jacob, what you are saying about their thinking makes a lot of sense. The psoric miasm being present in everyone, they think that everyone will need sulphur at some point.
Eventhough they will use other anti psorics remedies if needed based on the symptoms, they expect sulphur symptoms to show at some point, as they assume there is a sulphur layer in everyone.

Has there been any cases, where the psoric miasm has been removed completely without sulphur?

thank you

R

HI Rne,
Usually once a case is analysed in detail, there is alway some history of suppression. This includes use of antibiotics, antipyretics, analgesics, etc - do you know anyone who has not had one of these?

Often SUlphur is a very good remedy to remove these suppressions. This does not mean only prescribing on the miasm or constitution. This is an incomplete idea of the indication of SUlphur by some homeopaths. These prescritions are not based on the mental state or consitutional picture of Sulphur. Usually there is only a typical SUlphur type of irritability along with other indicative symptoms. Check that out.

I think your homeopath is a wise person and you should be asking him for his answers.

There are some articles on www.hpathy.com that you could read in this regard. Unfortunately, today there seems to be some interference on that server - and once the server/site is working properly, I"ll poste relevant links.
ALl the best,
dr. leela

__________________
http://www.homeopathy2health.com

Hi Doctorleela,

Thank you very much for your reply. So if i understand well, what you are saying is we will probably all need sulphur at some point, as we all have some history of suppression (I can't think of anyone that I have never had any antibiotics or analgesics..).

Thank you for the link, this is a massive website, what were the articles you were thinking about?

Thanks
R

HEre are a couple:

http://www.hpathy.com/philosophy/she...t-remedies.asp

http://www.hpathy.com/philosophy/dsouza-miasm.asp

__________________
http://www.homeopathy2health.com