I have gone through all the related topics on chalazion in various different homeopathy forums and literature , but now it seems that I have messed myself up. I haven't tried anything yet, but different opinions, different cases and different valued experiences shared in the forums have made me kind of confused about my situation.

MY CASE:
Ive had a Chalazion for 4 months now and it does not seem to be going. My Chalazion is solid and on my top-left eye lid. There is no pus comming out.. Im not even sure it has any pus in it... It started out as a stye, then got all soild and stayed there... Its size is small but it is noticable ! I want to get rid of it and I dont want to go through surgery and steroid injections.

FROM FORUMS:
- silicia 30
- hepar sulphris
- Arnica 30c
- antimonium tart (in forum it is said to be fast and removes rock hard chalazion in one day . is it ???).

FROM SOFTWARE (remedy grid on abchomeopathy.com)
- Apis Mellifica


After reading the related cases, these the different prescribed medicines. But which one should I use and how ?


I am completely new to homeopathy, I dont know abc of homeopathy, but one thing i know for sure is - IT CURES.

(Note: I am 23yrs old (if it matters) and I never had a chalazion in past)
I would like to ask dr. leela and all other experienced members (I am sorry I dont know you by names, plz forgive me) to please help me.

In anticipation,
~ME

Is there nothing I can do of my chalazion ??? Is there no medicine ???

Please help !

HI Jarvis,
I'm sorry I did not see your post earlier.

A Chalazion is not a condition to be alarmed about so give it time.

Secondly I'd suggest that you get proper homeopathic treamtent for it that is not necessarily focussed on the chalazion itself but on various other general charactersitcs existing at this point of time incuding your mental state.

I"D suggest that you see a homeoapth for individual treatment. All the people so far (including muself) that I"ve treated for a chalazion have responded though it may have taken a month or so to completely disappear. NO surgery, no injections. The important thing is that associated problems should als respond in a proper manner and direction.

So I'd suggest, get the proper homeopathic treatment rather than trying out remedies. IF you dont' have a reliable homeopath locally try the onine route.
HOpe this helps,
D.r Leela

__________________
http://www.homeopathy2health.com

Thank you DR. Leela for your reply, I felt good ! And no need to be sorry , I mean it !

I am presently new and staying in a small town in US, and I doubt if there is any homeopathy practitioner in my near viscinity.

Again, Is there any more details that I need to provide ? about my lifestyle or something ?

I read that staphysagaria, thuja, arnica are few of the medicines that have worked with most of the cases, would that work on me too ?

Thank you once again Dr. Leela. I really appreciate the patience you carry to read and respond back to almost all the idividual cases.

Regards,

HI,

Sorry you're from JArvis - you are not JArvis

Actually the prescription for a Chalazion is a 'constitutional' remedy. ANother way of saying, it is a Chronic remedy and not a specific remedy for the Chalazion in particular. Yes the remedies you mention are most commonly indicated in this condition, but the indications include much more than just the Chalazion, its symtpoms amd location.

So, yes your complete history will have to be evaluated and maybe a good option for you is to try the online route for consultation.
All the best!
d.r leela

__________________
http://www.homeopathy2health.com

Dear doctorleela,

Suppose this person comes to you for 'Chalazion'.What kind of questions would you like to ask.This is just for my personal knowledge.
I wait for your kind reply.
sajjad.

Hi SAjjad,
I would take the complete homeopathic history including the local symtoms of the chalazion.
IT is a procedure I follow, becasue often the Chalazion may NOT be the only problem a person has. We would never know if for example the person is diabetic or hypertensive or constipated or has other eye problems or is on other medication, ... if we did not ask. These are constitutional problems that have to be addressed along with the Chalazion otherwise our prescription can be detrimental or else our management is inappropriate.
D.r Leela

__________________
http://www.homeopathy2health.com

Dear D.r Leela,

Thank you for your kind and prompt reply.It means that you can prescribe on Chalazion plus hypertension plus diabetes plus constipation. Suppose a person has all these four then what will be the remedy ?.This is not to test you but i just want to know how can we reach to the proper remedy in the minimum possible time in general practice.See if we are capable to reach the right remedy withen few minutes believe you me we can defeat allopath.We must work on these lines.
We are physician here just to treat diseases people suffering from.I have gone through many homeopathic web sites but am really disappointed to know that we all are wasting time in non profitable,un-necessary,never reaching to an end discussions.We should concentrate to treat sick persons only.Discussion must be healthy and worthy.
If some one contact for his ailment,there are two common answers.
1.Contact a professional homeopath nearby.
2.Read the rules.
I dont think it is fair the only rule i know is to cure the patient with homeopathic medicines in the minimum possible time without much expenditures.
I am a qualified homeopath with thorough knowledge but what i can see on these forum is disappointing.
I am in contact with many homeopath to find out the easiest way to serve humanity that is why i am asking you the above mentioned question.I hope you wont mind that.I am not cheating any body.Hope you and others will reply.

sajjad.

Hi dr. Sajjad,
Deciding on what is characteristic in a case for prescription is an art that a homeopath learns with experience. so there may be are shortcuts he can take during a busy time in practice. OFten though this involves having a questionnaire or having other assistants fill out details in the history. Even if this is not possible, it is the wisdom of experience that helps make a decision whether a remedy is properly matched to be curative.

BEfore that, it is mandatory that EVERY beginning homeopath starts with taking the COMPLETE HISTORY for analysis. NO short cuts.

Once a history is in place, a homeopath is aware of HOW the precess of cure must take place. And so he can know whether the remedy chosen has acted curatively, palliatively or suppressively.

If a remedy chosen for chalazion removed the chalazion, but the patients diabetes gets out of control and the symtoms of hypertension begin to develop, the obviously the remedy is the wrong remedy. It has caused more trouble, even though the chalazion has disappeared.

IF someone has not taken the compete history, they will be under the FALSE impression that their remedy has cured a chalazion, while instead the remedy has caused suppression and more long term disease for the patient.

I don't think its possible to discuss hypothetically how one will prescribe for chalazion and diabeties and hypertention at the same time.
The ony way to prescribe a good remedy is to include the predominant PICTURE of characteristics at any POINT OF TIME ( physical particulars, mental, general) in the choice of the remedy.

Hope this helps,
d.r leela

__________________
http://www.homeopathy2health.com

doctorleela,

Thank you for your kind reply.Some of my questions are answered and some not.

I will post a questionnaire to this fellow and let us see his response.

sajjad.