You wrote:

< ..I believe that I have proved that my method is equal to your classical method and in some respects is even better as the cure is almost instantaneous. You must remember that the patient is looking for a quick cure and if Eczema can be cured within a week by Arnica, I do not think that it can harm the patient in any way.>

Joe, there is no such entity as an " almost instantaneous " cure and that no harm will come to the patient " if Eczema can be cured within a week by Arnica, ". The Central Nervous System and the Skin are derived from the same germinal layer in the embryo. There will be definite pathological reverberations in the nervous system but with no signs and symptoms in the interim. If you pursue the case long enough, you can be certain of manifestations, Anecdotally. I have heard of a case of unilateral
deafness not long after the resolution of some dermatological problem.

Post-influenza recovery is slow even though the patient may be ambulant.
A lacerated injury may have an uneventful recovery without any stitch abscess but the re-growth of the nerve fibriles in the cicatrice will take months.

With regards
Lew

Dear Joe, dear members
How much can your assumptions lead you astray? I am a qualified motor-mechanic with degree and 30 years experience. And I have studied medicine to the levels of a juniors doctors degree, and I am a musician for more than 30 years, a farmer on a small self sufficient farm of 8 ha, a homeopath indeed, a father of 5, a teacher in the middle length discourse of Buddha --is this enough??

My aim is not to attack you as a person or to discredit your efforts.

Continue your own thing and put your own name under it, maybe something like the Joe-de-Livera-therapy. Many have done that before, just to mention Schuessler, or Robert Bach. The test of time will show, whether it has value.
Why trying to fit it under the umbrella of homeopathy?

Homeopathy is defined in all aspects by Hahnemann in his organon and Chronic diseases. Anyone who comes along , (as you did) promoting a one- remedy – cure- all treatment of a disease name will be confronted with scepticism, and his ideas be taken to the test; to see if they are within or without the rules and principles of homeopathy. The result was: – your form of therapy failed the test.

The choice is yours: familiarize yourself with homeopathic rules and principles, work accordingly, get the deserved results and stay in this community, or continue your own way, call it your own therapy, start your own forum without interference of ,,negativity''.

There is one thing for sure -- the rules and principles of homeopathy will not change, as much as you and others wish they would, and the Organon will not rewrite itself to suit each and every allopath.

So -- good luck to yourself, whichever your choice may be.

__________________
Hans Weitbrecht
Consultant Homeopath

Hi Joe
Where can we get these items. For example, I stay in Bangalore, sometimes in Chennai. But I cannot ask the local shop keepers here for Spring Water. They would not understand. Is there any other commonly used term for this? Or will a bottled drinking water like Bisleri suffice? Also, will the local medical shops understand Nat Sulph 6c? Or should I go to some Homeopathy medical shop? Sorry about my ignorance on Homeopathy. But I want to try this desperately on my Mother.
She started having wheezing about 4 years back. She never has frequent cold or anything. But has cough and wheezing constantly. Basically, if she stands up and walks even a few steps, she starts panting. She just cannot do anything that involves a little bit of physical effort. She has been on Rotohalers for years, but it just gives some immediate releif, but basically her condition has become worse and worse as years passed by. And it is not seasonal, she has this throughout the year. She used to do a lot of household work all by herself and also go for job until 4 years back. But now she is just not able to even walk a few steps :-((. Especially, it will take about 10 minutes for her to climb a normal stair case of say 15 steps. And once she is up, she will just sit down immediately panting. Please advice on some effective treatment. She and I have been literally on tears frequently because of the trauma she is undergoing. Can her trauma be cured at all? If yes, how fast? And how? Please help us out.

I was interested to note that in spite of the many negative comments that you would surely have seen in the posts above by Cellsalts, Hans Weitbrecht and Kayveeh that you decided to ask me for advice on your mother's Asthma. I also noticed that Dr Leela in another post has urged you to consult a homeopath in your own city.

I believe that their joint attitude against my method of cure is because I do not abide by the strict classical method of treatment which these homeopaths use as they have been all brainwashed into believing that it is only their classical method of treatment that can help cure an ailment like your mother's Asthma. I can assure you however that it is only very rarely that my method fails as the results are visible in a few hours or days.

The method I use is the direct method used in medicine to treat the ailment or disease directly with a remedy, instead of the classical homeopathic method where the causative factors and the ailment are repertorized and the remedy identified after a consultation which usually takes about an hour.

Answers to your queries:
deleted - unhomeopathic advice.

MODERATION:Your method is allopathic. You've openly admitted this. This is a homeopathic forum - not allopathic.

JOE PLEASE REFRAIN FROM GIVING UNHOMEOPATHIC PRESCRIPTIONS HERE ON THIS FORUM. You've been asked before - please heed the warning.

__________________
Joe De Livera
Colombo
Sri Lanka