Mose has not read my contribution properly - or has misunderstood it. I only mentioned ONE remedy - pointing out that the plant Pulsatilla has a high sulphur content .
Constitutional prescribing is accurate if all the info is available . Suggest Mose reads up on Pulsatilla and gets the feel of the remedy.

The problem in this case is what is the cause. You must understand that homeopathy is not only what do we see today (but very important) but in this case I see "hurt" and perhaps you could go back to the pre and post birth and there you find the answers or what about the father?

Passkey I do understand remedies but I am not focused on one or two and on nosodes. The world is sligtly more complicated, sorry

Mose!
I thought about what you said.
I can recall a pneumonia followed by a kidney-infection while being pregnant with her. I felt so out of breath while having the pneumonia, I feared suffocation. I didn't get anything for it, as I can remember, cause my doctor told me (later I left him, realising he didn't doing anything at all, outside calling me back for weekly visits) that being pregnant makes it inadviseable to take any medication. My daughter must had been short of oxigen too during my pneumonia, as there was meconium in the amniotic fluid, old one (being brown, rather green) when she was born, about 2 months later. She was born with epidural (my next 2 was homebirths...)and had an issue with low blood sugar. A week later she got back to hospital, with severe jaundice, which was dealed with by fluorescent light therapy. She was a bad feeder, but only because she just wouldn't sign if she was hungry, just lay peacefully - I had to change to scedule-nursing, and that was the solution. We realised the first problem with her after her first DPTP shot. She got two more of this, and no more vaccines after that.
Her father had epilepsy in her school-age, which he outgrown. In my falmily the vision-problem run among the women members, also my grandma and her 4 sisters could have been diagnosed as pituitary dwarves, would there be any kind of knowledge of this in their time. Also they all was nearsighted, and 2 of them became blind at old age.
Do you see more clearly now? Have any suggestion based on this?
Monika

While taking the history into account, it's really important to list what is going on NOW - so you know what is uppermost and active at present.

Silica and Pulsatilla are closely related remedies. It's not uncommon for someone who needs Silica to then need Pulsatilla for an acute, or vice-versa.

Good luck!!

__________________
"The significance of a fact is measured by the capacity of the observer."
Carroll Dunham

Taking into account aversion to Fat, Milk agg. like to swim in the see etc. we cannot exclude a natrium salt in this case and I suggest that you study this further.

There is no need for the good Doctor to shout , from behind a wall of prejudice & lack of experience. I will note his OPINION . Although it does remind me of the note that often appears in the notes of politicians – [ weak point here ; SHOUT]
However I think it as well, having considered the CONSTITUTIONAL aspect of this case and arrived at a constitutional remedy – namely Pulsatilla., that we look at the Miasmatic influences displayed.
The older more experienced homeopaths considered that syphilis was the ‘Shape Changer’ . Wherever the body deviated significantly from the average in form it was considered that the genetic heritage was influenced by the syphilitic miasm. Abnormal height , abnormal obesity [ such as was the case of Orson Wells ] abnormal shortness , abnormal sight [ my mother was 4ft 11inches and had great astigmatism] one must look at the syphilitic Miasm.
I was lucky , my father’s genes were largely Psoric and I ended up with the main miasm in my makeup being Tubercular. Which is, of course made up of the genetic combination of syphilis/psora. Where the syphilitic miasm was dominant in my mother,my fathers influence caused it to become recessive in me. It is high time the geneticists located these affects. But one assumes that they do not believe in homeopathy .
The Arab physicians often used gold leaf , rubbed into the gums , as an anti-syphilitic. The irony is that, the gold that Spain brought back from the new world, was accompanied by syphilis. Which spread across Europe in the 1500/1600’s Compton Burnett wrote a book on” Gold as a remedy in disease “ and he used it in many cases of unbalanced development . Notably breasts of differing sizes, and undescended testicles as well as many types of heart anomalies and visual problems.
We have here a number of clues that point to the syphilitic miasm . Body size , sight , etc. This should be reflected in any further treatment .

With all respect for experience but most homeopaths consider Pulsatilla as a sycotic remedy,

For ppmoni when I asked about the relationship with the father I was more interesting in the personal relationship between the daughter and the father.

Mose!

I'm divorced (living with my second husband). My daughter's father is very uncaring about his children, coming to see them maybe 6-10 weekly, not paying after them, bringing stupid suprises for them for eg. as a birthday present. The children are ambivalent toward him, my son don't like him, my younger daughter is mainly disappointed, BUT my older daughter, who's constitution we are talking here, is clinging onto him. She drinks his words, and would listen for hours to talk she didn't understand at all (he used to talk about high science to even the kindergarten-aged one).

Passkey!
After much reading, it seems to me that she is rather Puls. (Although I'm saying this while not knowing Ambra Grisea at all, which was suggested by someone, mainly based on "always talks in questions" and "not thirstly". Do you know more about this remedy? I didn't find much in my souces.)
Thanks: Monika

monika,

1) the mm mentions silicea as a chronic of puls.

2) as I wrote elsewhere - to me it appeared like puls.

3) you failed to understand what I tried to convey to you about homeopathy.

4) how did you assume that I am self taught / self read homeopath ?
I have a registered qualification for homoeopathy as well. however. I consider myself a student of this great science. homeo is a study of a lifetime.

5) it takes a long time to understand the hering's laws and see them in the follow up for cure.

6)many times the wrong remedy may show improvement in a particular potency.

nice to know that some members of this forum, understood the value of the advice that I gave in 2 previous posts.
the warnings should be remembered by all of us and that includes me.

monika, the idea was not to discourage or hurt you.
I wrote with love and concern.

wrong use of homeo potentized remedies can be disasterous.

dr manish agarwala