Quote:

Quote: Dr. Masroor: i want to know how did he cure the patient by expelling his stones. wht mdicine he used? Lisaannan: Why don't you ask Dr Khalid?

Sorry Dr. masroor you are not satisfied with dr. khalid's answers and again you were being refered back to him. Let me explains few things to you.

Every thing in this world is not materialistic in nature. We recognized things through observations and experimentations, and then we try to find conclusions. Hakeem (herbalist) also use “Pather Thore” (a kind of herb for expelling stones from the kidney) extensively. They are equally successful in breaking and expelling stones from kidneys. Their philosophy is different. We also use medicine for breaking stones but our philosophy is entirely different. Their philosophy of understanding action of herbal medicine is based on material and our is based on immaterial. An example is of “Thinking” which is immaterial but it starts working through material. Brain is material but it generates immaterial thing just like “thinking”. Homeopathy is that system is opposite to material to immaterial i.e. we give immaterial substance (homeopathic potency) to body (which is material in nature). The best-illustrated example could be, suppose that you are hungry but suddenly you got news that your beloved mother has been expired. You have seen in your practice that in such cases patients lost appetite. Why? When you gave no physical punishment. Actually that was the pulse, which you send in the body by announcing bad news, which shaken the whole body and you vital force got detracked or disturbed. In the same way, we also give immaterial substance in the form of potency to our patients having already disturbed or low state of vital force, our medicines (immaterial substance) enhance the vital force of the body. This actually the vital force, which then covers up ailments.

First, You need to understand the concept of vital force which is immaterial in nature. All we got from observations and experimentations. An other example of gravitational force. This force is immaterial in nature but without having gravitational force, we cannot pass even stool? Have you seen that force with your naked eyes? But this do exist…

__________________
KN

Why would you be sorry Masroor was referred back to Dr Khalid?
Dr Khalid knows the remedy he used to cure his patient. We don't. Do you?
Dr Khalid will know what he knows about anatomy/physiology, etc. We don't know what his education is. Do you? I didn't think so.

As for the rest - it's open for discussion - e.g. vital force/principle/law of cure etc -- all of which is found in the Organon.

Members participate, in general, for discussion of various topics having to do with homeopathy. Not everyone participates here to teach others the very basics of homeopathy. It's quite reasonable to refer people to the very sources we used ourselves to learn the basics.

__________________
"The significance of a fact is measured by the capacity of the observer."
Carroll Dunham