Jonh,

The above three posts are irrelevant. Their deletion will help keep the thread to the point. Thanks

Ghazi,

How are you doing with responses?

Snoopy

Cherished Member Dr. Ghazi

Please answer these questions so that I could send you my recommendation.

What part of the night did he wet the bed?

WAS there any burning before and after urination?

WAS the urine acrid, black, bloody, brown, clear, cloudy, cold or hot?

What was the ODOR or smell?

I hope you will reply soon.

Medical Officer, there is no questionnaire in homeopathy, why are you asking such legitimate questions specially about the smell of the urine.? :razz: This has been said in the past by a member on this board that homeopathy has no rules and regulations. This is all about hit and trial method. There is no base of homeopathy. Dr. Ghazi is trying to prove that non-sense approach by saying that just treat the patient without taking FULL CASE. (conclusion = Irresponsible Case Taking )

P.S, Please don't think that we are after Dr. Ghazi, We are just trying to push him out from confusion state. This has been decided in the PML gp.

[ 30. May 2003, 03:35: Message edited by: Homoeo Dr. M Aqeel ]

__________________
<b>Homoeopathic Doctor Aqeel Choudhary<br />House No. 132, Block VI,Jinnah Colony, Kharian City.</b>

What kind of mood your's doctors patient had ... weeping or cheerful? If a homeopath recommend lycopodium in high potency then single dose act well. This is deep acted remedy and rarely be repeated after one dose?
Sulphur is not recommended at night? This creates un-easiness in the patient.

[ 31. May 2003, 17:55: Message edited by: Secret Agent ]

An e-mail with the name of the curative remedy has been sent to all those who responded.

__________________
Best regards<br />Ghazi<br /><a href="http://www.sph.homeoweb.net" target="_blank">www.sph.homeoweb.net</a>

Hello fittness again

Here you can see the conflicting drama, a question was put forwarded and was asked to guess for a remedy. Few questions were raised by different members, The drama director oversighted the questions and then reply regarding remedy name was sent privately. My question is what do we gain from this thread. Nothing.

This is a mere try for advertisment of society web site. This case will be available sooon on the same site then we will be asked to visit the site for knowing the name of remedy. This is a point is of confliction. Wastage of time and nothing else. No body gained any thing.

This discussion board is for learning and getting knowledge. For discussing different techniques how did the doctor reach at selected remedy. What was in his mind when he prescribed the remedy. Which principle of homeopathy, he followed. We gained nothing.

If a Pakistani will say all these things so bodly then ultimately dr. ghazi and other members would certainly not like this kind of reply or post.

This is the difference between pakistani and other members. Most Pakistani have the opinion that you have to prove something logically and you can't force the point. If the patient got cured then how? When dr. ghazi is saying that symptoms are so easy to recognize. Then why those four renowned doctors unable to find the exact remedy for that patient? Why. They were not homeopaths?

This the post which they call trolling posts. This is the post, they will call annoying post. But this has been decided in PML, don't care about the others if you want to learn homeopathy. Say what ever you want to say but in descent manner.

I challenge that this case was not real. If it is real I want to meet that patient. If dr. Ghazi will tell me the address of that patient, it will take me hardly a week or so to reach karachi. I want to visit that patient at Karachi myself.

[ 02. June 2003, 11:56: Message edited by: Homoeo Dr. M Aqeel ]

__________________
<b>Homoeopathic Doctor Aqeel Choudhary<br />House No. 132, Block VI,Jinnah Colony, Kharian City.</b>

Dear Members
Carolor approached me to have a look at this case under the aspect of selection of iodum for the case presented.

Undoubtingly, the main-complaint is found in the urinary area –on the one hand the enuresis, and on the other hand the frequent urination and this very peculiar feeling , that there is still a Urine left after the Urination which can actually be expressed.
There is also the dream before it happens.

There were other symptoms found of a more general character, such as hunger, &lt; fasting, or emaciation, as well as loquacity. These symptoms are common to many patients and also common to many remedies and therefore do not form part of the decisive symptom-picture.

In order to narrow it down I went to the BB2 repertory, and compared the following rubrics:
Enuresis page: 627
Urination frequent too: 626
After Urination Dribbling: 634

The more common ones were:
Hunger excessive: 472
Emaciation: 805
Heat&lt;: 1150
Fasting&lt;: 1118

The selection of Iodum is interesting, as it matches the common features of the case very well, but on the main-complaint it is clearly lacking.
Iodum does not have in its symptoms:

‘’two or three drops remain in the urethra that come out on straining.’’

Throughout my comparison, I did not find a remedy which dreamt of urination and then had enuresis, so this symptom, even though very peculiar does not bring us any closer to the most appropriate remedy.

My choice fell on Calc-c, which has this feeling of incomplete urination [ see CD: 886], and the enuresis in a characteristic manner. It does not contradict the other more common features, und would have been certainly a good match.

__________________
Hans Weitbrecht
Consultant Homeopath

Hans objections to the selection of Iodum have been conveyed to the concerned homoeopath and his reply, that is, if he sends one, would be pasted here as soon as received.

__________________
Best regards<br />Ghazi<br /><a href="http://www.sph.homeoweb.net" target="_blank">www.sph.homeoweb.net</a>

Hans, would you take time to study the second case and e-mail your choice?

__________________
Best regards<br />Ghazi<br /><a href="http://www.sph.homeoweb.net" target="_blank">www.sph.homeoweb.net</a>