It was the arnica that did it.

What good news.

Is it possible to give us the details of how Arn was given? What potency, how frequently, dry doses or in dilution, how long till symptoms showed improvement, etc? What about the other "confusion" type symptoms? It would be very nice to have this information to file away.

Hope the caregivers appreciated your efforts but if not, the cat certainly does. Good job.

__________________
Sometimes on Earth, you can find something that resembles a little piece of Heaven. And sometimes on Earth, a little piece of Heaven can find you.

WHAT,IS IT TRUE BUT DETAILS(CONVINCING)

check out the pet section, sir.

How could you say it was arnica who did work when you tried other remedies at first instance and did not wait for their action. when other main sudden blindness symptom's medicines were also overruled. Please explain...

You're absolutely right...it could have been the other two remedies that were tried. They were each only given once with no change whatsoever. We really don't know if it was the arnica that helped. And they only noticed about a week ago that the cat was definately seeing. But after the arnica..they did notice that her eyes were responding to light...they didn't notice that after the other two remedies. I don't know what else to say.

And besides...what real difference could it make which remedy helped her...we don't know the etiology of her blindness. Something worked...this is good.

And I'm not a homeopath...so I don't have to wait patiently and go back after a week to check out the cat..after each remedy. It was a huge deal for me to go there on two separate occasions. Since I've seen many remedies in my day work in a split second..I'm of the school that if it doesn't work right away..its probably not the right remedy. Now I'm sure people will be writing in here discouraging me from going to school in homeopathy.

Thankyou very much for admiting all these things. "I am not homeopath". This the most simple answer to get rid off from non-sense funny stories which you commonly put on this bb. You start like a genius and then some one with very low common sense respond logically then it is the best way to come out from the track by saying that "I am not homeopath". This kind of habit we have observed so many times from many members including those who are still discussing and appreciating on your lie story. This is not the way to give credit to homeopathy. Bye doing so you and members like you are not doing sympathy with homeopathy. You know many non-homeopaths are also reading this general discussion forum. What will they think. As seelishah very rightly pointed out here.

For Non- Homeopaths,

Let’s repertorize the case once again for studying point of view!

According to your opinion it was sudden loss of vision due to missing of friend cat

1. My point is Arnica does not come under this category or it does not have sudden blindness symptoms or any other symptom, so it has no link with this case. If you or your care take has used it then it was all-ineffective.

You prescribed aconite and nat mur and did not wait

2. Aconite has duration of action from 1 hour to several weeks. It means when you prescribed arnica. Aconite was in cat’s body and its action was going on in cat’s circulatory system. You also given Nat mur. It’s duration of action is 40-50 days. When arnica was given it was also in its body.

3. In my opinion the cause of sudden loss of vision was not known to you. It was your opinion that the cat was missing her friend but actually it was not.

Arnica is the complementary remedy to aconite in bruises or injury to eye. It acts well after the administration of aconite. When you prescribed arnica it might complete the action of aconite. Am I right?

The problem was started before 02 Jan 2003 and you gave first dose to cat at 06 Jan 2003, almost after a week after the start of problem

4. According to NASH, when the case is old arnica works well in high potency, it should not be given in cut, abrasion and wound in low potency in early stages of the case. The case was almost a week old. So you can’t expect or take best result in low potency in this case.

5. In sudden loss of vision, if you put delay in treating your patient. It will never recover. You generally have very short time to think. You lost too many days in your first prescription.

Issue of Fatty tissue in sudden blindness

Never think about fatty tissue involvement in sudden blindness. It never comes suddenly.

Cat care taker started dosing arnica on 9 jan 2003. Doses were given almost three days.

Eye’s cells need more time to recover once gone in blindness then the other body cells. The credit was given to Arnica which needs approx a week or so. It was not arnica who brought vision back rather it was duration of time which is needed to a body’s immune and natural healing system to respond. Secondly aconite acted as catalyst and played rule in enhancing speedy recovery. Arnica does not fit properly or no more near to this case.

Arnica is the complementary remedy to aconite in bruises or injury to eye. It acts well after the administration of aconite. When you prescribed arnica it might complete the action of aconite. Am I right?

Your care taker also used antibiotics and other medicines at the same time. How could you say the cat has recovered after the use of arnica and not from aconite, nat mur and antibiotics

This is not the way to give credit to homeopathy?

I am astonised to read in pet's forum where members are appreciating on fake and funny story.

Another thing I observed cat was not treat in front of carol even then members are foring her to put this funny cure in cured cases. This also tells the criteria of cured cases already have in HHBB.

Carol for Bhagwan sake don't put it in cured cases box.

[ 09. February 2003, 21:28: Message edited by: DR.SAM ]

__________________
<b>Sam Symptomatologist and homeopathician</b>

so we have nat mur + bell + aconite & arnica for sudden blindness in cat. Is this correct? I know that we can use the same formula in dogs complain too.

__________________
Muhammad Raza Hussain<br />Z.C Post Graudate College