Thank you Anna,

Does it boil down to being only able to treat functional problems and psychological cases where there is no degeneration of tissue or pathology, because of the one-dose, high potency method; and prescribing on the mentals as being the soil that gives rise to the physical complaints?

My teacher, Robin Murphy, says that you can't treat pathology with this method, that this "fundamental" or "constitutional" layer is beneath the pathology; that after you've given the daily dose of Conium for the prostate cancer, or Cann-s. for the gonorrheal infection, you can then go treat the "whole Person". Is this what you're referring to when you say the colleges aren't teaching the Hahnemannian method?

Snoopy

My dear Anna and Ghazi,

I gave my opinion on the subject case. I will again say that this specific case requires immediate management, which can easily be done in other system. I am in homoeopathic field for the last 20 years. Even Acupuncture has no result in this case. It is just like in dehydration where you require injectable saline water for immediate recovery and after the recovery, one can switch over to homoeopathy for restoration of health. Every system of medicine has its own advantages and disadvantages. The big advantage of homeopathy is, it has cure of many diseases. But it has no case management. The big disadvantage of allopathy is, it has many side effects and suppression of symptoms but the main advantage is quick management. You can disagree as you have the right.

After reading your remarks. A joke came to my mind. Please listen it first

A farmer came to his friend and said his cow is suffering from fever. His friend told him that I have a good prescription for your cow as I have a good experience of this kind fever. Go and apply over her. The farmer went to his home and applied the same technique over the cow. The cow as a result died. The farmer again visited to his friend and said my cow is died due to your prescription. What was happened when you applied your technique to your own cow? The friend said “my cow also died due to my technique”

The same situation is here. Anna is saying my advice is contradictory. I challenge you if any competent homeopaths or allopaths reject my opinion. I will leave this forum.

Look at your opinion

Let’s watch

1. jacobspj (patient) belongs to united kingdom. Was advised to visit to some competent homoeopath. Then said you will not find competent homoeopath in UK. What a stupid thing I ever listened from a member. Tell me where the patient will go for its recovery. Is the right opinion? Referring to competent homeopath and saying at the same time you will not find it.

2. The blunder in your remarks is the challenging of competency of homoeopath. I will not allow you to say any word over the competency of homoeopath. You are causing great confusion among the patients. The patients have no concern about the Hahnemannian system and others. It is contradictory too. After reading your opinion, every layman user, when visit his/her homoeopath. The first question which he/she will ask to the doctor about his/her way of treatment. Do you have all tools available to treat me?

Look at this para. Patient has been referred to competent homoeopath. (Which is not available in UK)

It has been told to the patient that there are different system in homoeopathy. Hahnemannian is the best. (If by chance the patient will find any homoeopath, he will be remain confused about the system)

In the last, advice was given not to take self treatment. Now tell me where the patient will go.

My dear jacobspj,

I am sorry. We homoeopath can not stand at one point.

You can read other posts too which are displayed under Anna's post and read all conflictions among the homoeopaths.

__________________
<b>DR. MUJAHID HUSSAIN, DHMS, DCA (SRILANKA), RHMP<br />TAHIR HOMOEOPATHIC AND ACUPUNCTURE CLINIC, KHAN BAHADUR PLAZA,<br />CIRCULAR ROAD, GUJRAT STATE </b>

glumerulo nephritis is a risky and dangerous condition. It requires careful handling of case. It could be dangerous at any time. Hospitilzation is the first step in these type of cases.

German Repotorium has given adviced not to treat these type of cases independently. Some time it need effective antibiotic treatment. Other wise Ig type protein level will increase which results in kidney failure.

__________________
<b>Lady Dr. Meena</b>

Hi,

I do not understand why you people argue about my case... so much that doubts have crept into mind...it is ideal for my case.?

And one more thing.. to be frank with you.. ladies and gentlemen..you haven't read my case history properly..and make me a high risk patient!.

The fact is that I had glumerulo nephritis 18 years ago and i do not have a problem since then. All my vital functions are normal indicated by normal blood urea, creatinine and glumerulus filtration rates. I am having this elavated blood pressure for 2 years now.

I was curious to know about alternative therapy since the specific betablocker i use to control the blood pressure(Renal hypertension !!) makes me very tired..I did not intend to create any confusion among you.

I still want to give it a try and would like to know if there is any classical homeopath trained the Hanneman's way in UK.

I am sorry to create such confusion and I do not consider myself a high risk patient as people make out.

I would really appreciate your suggestions and thoughts in this regard.

Hope to hear from you,

S. Jacob

Dear S. Jacob
I also saw your other postings und understand your concern as a patient.
My answer as a practitioner is: ''depends on''.
This might not satisfy your need for a quick answer, but please understand, that we as homeopaths can only make a informed statement , if we have all the details of your case.
Quite understandibly we take our cases in privat, and after having gained a good overview, we then can advice you what cause of action is appropriate. and furthermore, you as a patient have the right to be taken serious.

Hans Weitbrecht
Homeopath

__________________
Hans Weitbrecht
Consultant Homeopath
homeopathy study guide: http://www.homeopathyworldcommunity....hy-study-guide

Dear Homoeo Dr. Mujahid

You as a homeopath, and therefore following homeopathic principals as they are laid out in Hahnemann’s Organon, will certainly remember Par: 52 in the Organon which reads:

‘’There are but two principal methods of cure: the one based only on accurate observation of nature, on careful experimentation and pure experience, the homeopathic (before me never designedly used) and a second which does not do this, the heteropathic or allopathic. Each opposes the other, and only he who does not know either can hold the delusion that they can ever approach each other or even become united, OR TO MAKE HIMSELF SO RIDICULOUS AS TO PRACTISE AT ONE TIME HOMOEOPATHICALLY AT ANOTHER ALLOPATHICALLY, ACCORDING TO THE PLEASURE OF THE PATIENT; a practice which may be called criminal treason against divine homeopathy.’’

As I am convinced that you follow this paragraph, I cannot understand your advice given in your first post.
I also fail to understand how you can make any judgement by the little information provided, taken into account that you practised for 20 years, and therefore must have seen and treated similar cases.

If you are interested in homeopathic casework being done in similar cases, you are welcome to pay a visit to my clinic and convince yourself about the possibilities homeopathy offers.

__________________
Hans Weitbrecht
Consultant Homeopath
homeopathy study guide: http://www.homeopathyworldcommunity....hy-study-guide

When I first entered on this site. I read maximum posts of various members. I know maximum of them. You can see that most of the members have fictitious names. A thief will never give you the address of contact. I still own my advice. My advice was correct for this specific case. I took full responsibility of the case. At least I can assure on this ground that full address and name is written on my homepage. I also mentioned the phone numbers. A thief will never give you his address.

www.geocities.com/ninjaforall/questions.htm

Hans,

It is against the philosophy of homeopathy. Our philosophy is to increase the vital force of the patient. We give medicines to the patient and not for the disease. While allopathic medicines are for diseases. So both have different actions on the body. I never prescribed any allopathic medicines to my patient in my life. But I know the limitation of homeopathy. Every system of medicine has its own limitation. When I need, I refer the patient to allopath for case management to protect the life of patient. I am the only person who is receiving many referred patients from allopath daily. Seven MBBS doctors are also teaching in my college.

We have to serve the ailing humanity. From which system?. It is not mentioned in organon. This is the main cause. Read 1st ten aphorisms of organon. First we are doctors and not homeopathic promoters.

To me the information is complete i.e glomeru nephritis.

some of the symptoms or disesaes are (I copied it recently from other title)

Disease………………… Attributes
1. Oliguria
2. Edema
3. Edema – facial
4. Edema – periorbital
5. Edema – ankle
6. Headache
7. Visual disturbances
8. Blurred vision
9. Hematurea – microscopic or gross
10. Hypertension
11. Anorexia
12. Nausea
13. Vomiting
14. Pain – Lower back
15. Creatinine clear – endogenous –
16. ASO titer (+) streptococal inf
17. Sedimentation rate +
18. Leukocytes +
19. Hemoglobin –
20. Erythrocytes –
21. BUN +
22. Cholesterol – serum +
23. pH – serum –
24. Proteinuria
25. Casts

Thanks for your offer to visit your clinic. I am a poor man. I can not afford such heavy expenses to visit. However I am going to invite you. I will bear all your expenditure from Lahore Air Port to my home. I will stand at the air port with my car. I will be your driver. You will stay in Pakistan for fifteen days. I will take you in all homeopathic clinics in Pakistan. Maximum are my students.

Ten year ago when I visited Germany. I brought a repertorium. I will search for that repertorium (Homoeopathic) and will quote more remarks from them. Wait

__________________
<b>DR. MUJAHID HUSSAIN, DHMS, DCA (SRILANKA), RHMP<br />TAHIR HOMOEOPATHIC AND ACUPUNCTURE CLINIC, KHAN BAHADUR PLAZA,<br />CIRCULAR ROAD, GUJRAT STATE </b>

Hallo Homoeo Dr. Mujahid

Thanks for your kind invitation to come to Pakistan which I would love to follow.
Only, at the moment my clinic does not allow the time to travel abroad, because I cannot find an appropriate homeopath stepping in while I am gone.

By the way, did you notice, that Hahnemann throughout the Organon always refers to the disease to be treated and not to the person?
To treat the person and not the disease is the opinion of J.T. kent, and does not reflect homeopathic principals as laid down by Hahnemann.

You wrote:
&gt;&gt;We give medicines to the patient and not for the disease.&lt;&lt;
I would be very interested to learn what your criteria are for giving remedies, if it is not the disease signs and symptoms anymore.

Is human existence disease?

Looking forward to your reply.

__________________
Hans Weitbrecht
Consultant Homeopath
homeopathy study guide: http://www.homeopathyworldcommunity....hy-study-guide

I am very very very very happppppy. Atleast you did not ask any further question on my previous reply which I gave to you on your previous post and posted me a new question. :razz: It means you are satisfied with my previous answer and posted a new question for me.

Exams are going to be held in my homoeopathic college. I will not be available frequently.

Allah Hafiz (Good bye)

__________________
<b>DR. MUJAHID HUSSAIN, DHMS, DCA (SRILANKA), RHMP<br />TAHIR HOMOEOPATHIC AND ACUPUNCTURE CLINIC, KHAN BAHADUR PLAZA,<br />CIRCULAR ROAD, GUJRAT STATE </b>