Has anyone any experience of these ?
There are so many homeopaths prescribing them alongside remedies these days.

Comments please??

[ 23 February 2002, 13:37: Message edited by: Hoppitt415 ]

I have seen several cases of colloidal silver creating proving symptoms of Arg. Nit. in patients.

I guess they are just like supplements. For that reason, I don't think they are necessary.

Divina

__________________
...and deliverance has many faces<br />but grace<br />is an aquaintance of mine

If so many homeopaths are doing prescription and if they are getting results then there is no need to present old philosophical thoughts from organon.

Anna Bryant, When you are your self saying that so many are using then what is hesitation, not to accept. I don't think so we can get proving so easily on each and every medication.

__________________
Hafeez
Forum Pk

Excuse me Dr Mas but Anna has not replied to this topic ???????????!!!!!!!!!!

I was not saying that I did not accept the use of these minerals I was just asking if anyone had any experience of them

And, if so many doctors are getting "apparent" results from vaccination, antibiotics, steriods, etc., etc., is there again "no need to present old philosophical thoughts from Organon"? Because, these "methods" are not damaging, are they?

And, if TCM provides so many "apparent" results, is there again "no need to present old philosophical thoughts from Organon"?

And, if psychiatrists provide so many "apparent" results using prozac, ritalin, lithium, etc., etc., would you say, again, "no need to present old philosophical thoughts from Organon"? After all, these drugs are harmless and they have no side effects, do they?

And if [fill in your own therapy here] provides us with so many "apparent" results, would you say, again, "no need to present old philosophical thoughts from Organon"?

And yet, aren't these therapies palliative, suppressive, or, at worst, destructive? Do they cure according to the laws of nature? If what's in the Organon and Chronic Diseases works (when followed to the letter), why bother adding and/or changing it? I wonder?

Could it be: ego?

Could it be: people don't know how to follow the method set out in the Organon and CD, and so when they fail to get results, they construct a new system/methodology? Add bits and pieces here and there to "supplement" their inadequacy?

Hmm, so a proving can not be conducted using MTs? A proving cannot be done if you only take a remedy in the same potency twice? That would invalidate a lot of provings that have been conducted.

Minerals and acids have the capacity to alter the health of [wo]man. So, when we conduct a proving a change in lifestyle and/or diet is distinctly discouraged because it may affect the proving.

However, the quote above would argue that it has no effect. Therefore it is okay to prescribe minerals, acids alongside remedies. Well, I ask this:

When the patient returns for a follow-up, which has done the work?

[ 03 April 2002, 07:23: Message edited by: Simone ]

__________________
Regards,<br /><b>Simone H</b><br /><br /><i>Aude Sapere</i><br /><br />"Never be a passive listener or learner" ~ Christian Gottfried Hahnemann

Hop,

I have no idea what are you talking about Any thing wrong

__________________
Hafeez
Forum Pk

Dr Mas
In your post on April 1 you refer to Anna Bryant and she has never been part of this discussion !

K Krista- working in a cat shelter - how wonderful!
(I am a home checker for the local cat orphanage- I love it)

Thanks for your observations.
Seems to be a bit of a sales drive on colloidal minerals etc at the moment- I received a tape about it the other day. I know 1 homeopath round here who uses it.
i can only think it will confuse the 'picture' if given alongside remedies.

Hop, sorry I am bothering you again. I am really confussed. What I have done. [img]redface.gif[/img] Pleaes quote. So that I could edit my post. thanks

__________________
Hafeez
Forum Pk

Dr mas
In your post on 1 April (12.03)
Was it an April Fool joke ?

'Anna Bryant, When you are your self saying that so many are using then what is hesitation, not to accept. I don't think so we can get proving so easily on each and every medication. '

When did Anna join in this discussion ???

We used Collidial Silver in the cat shelter for some time. We added it to the water as a preventative. It apparently has antibiotic as well as antifungal properties. Not sure if it helped or not at any rate it did not do miraculas healing or anything (we still had ringworm and URI) and it was cut from the budget due to enormous expense of it, but occassional I will use in tap water in the attempt to kill unwanted organisims; doesn't do anything for the chemicals though. The literature claims it was used before antibiotics were discovered for infection etc. Sorry not much help, but you should be able to find info on it.