Schizophrenia appears to be a shifting homeopathy
remedy picture in a case being closely wached.A patient
is constantly on allopathic medication for five years.
Only improvement is in infrequent acute episode but
resulting in blunted intelligence and paucity of emotional
symtoms. only cravings / disliking of certain food, need
for sleep, flatulance, tongue symptoms, frequently
catching of cold etc. are observed. Recently he was
asked meaning of 'pedantic' (he was not expected to
know) he answered; he had heard pediatrics inconection
with child treatment and not pedantic (very normal
response) but when he is asked how he feels in certain
situations, he remains reflecting but never answering.
References of cases treated is
invited
nareshsinha@homeopathyhome.net

[ 07 January 2002: Message edited by: nareshsinha ]</p>

__________________
Schizophrenia

Judyth Reichenberg-Ullman, in her book
PROZAC-FREE has a chapter on schizophrenia; you might want to order it. www.minimum.com

Snoopy

dear naresh
your case history presents theDID feaures with disease picture better stop all medicines first and let the symptoms be clear
pksinha

__________________
Dr.P.K.Sinha

Dr Sinha,

How do you see DID symptoms?

Thanks.

__________________
Kescah

dear keshcah! probably dr. sinha has based it on patient
response to 'pedantic'. i incline to agree, but of course
we dare not since he had acute episode with or without
(for limited period. say a month) allopathic medicines,not
volatile but for managing and keeping him inhouse.

flatulence tongue as explined . i don't say he won"t have schizophrenia but the pts clear picture can only be obsrved after antidoting the hazards of drgs given to him

__________________
Dr.P.K.Sinha

Dear Doctors,

Are we talking about Dissociative Identity Disorder? Is that diagnosed by such things? I am not arguing, but curious. I know DID is often misdiagnosed as schizophrenia, so apparently this is what we are talking about.

Sorry, do not mean to change the subject, you can email me separately if you'd like.

__________________
Kescah

Dear kes
I SIMPLY MEAN TO SAY THE PRESENTATION OF SYMPTOMS MAY BE MIXED WITH DRUG SYMPTOMS WHICH WILL NOT ENABLE TO FIN A CORRECT REMEDY

__________________
Dr.P.K.Sinha

Dear kes
I SIMPLY MEAN TO SAY THE PRESENTATION OF SYMPTOMS MAY BE MIXED WITH DRUG SYMPTOMS WHICH WILL NOT ENABLE TO FINd A CORRECT REMEDY I think i am clear now
thanks

__________________
Dr.P.K.Sinha

It appears that topic has not generated interest-NO
further posts. TOPIC IS"WHETHER SOME CASES BY
WHATEVER NAME GROUP OF SYMPTOMS ARE LABLLED
IN MEDICAL TERMs, REVOLVE ROUND VARIOUS
REMEDIES BACK AND FORTH OR SIMULTANEOUSLY
HAVING MORE THAN ONE REMEDY PICTURE

__________________
Schizophrenia