Assembly line homeopathy is allopathy!

------------------
Homeopat MNNH Geir E.T. Marcussen
email: getm@eunet.no
http://www.homeopati.no

As you recomend me, i recommend you mr Lachesis.

So what is it Veratrum or Lach? Assembly line homoeopathy is homoeopathy, as long as the similimum is prescribed. Zinc in mgs is allopathy, especially when mixed with other remedies..

Well, then you are allopathy, as you in fact have a human body, and one of its components, in fact is zink, and you also find zink in food, so you cant eat that since it is allopahty, what? Do you potentize up the food as well, and dont take it in otherways?
Your quarraling desire is enormous, i must say, sorry but i dont have the time to play around with you anymore, but dont worry, you will soon find replacements.

Thanks for the tip, but I do not really see what I have done wrong, except sharing my experience. If that is a problem to you, I am sorry, I do not mean to be childish. As far as I know I back up every statement with the relevant quotes from the literature and present things as they are. I do not seek any quarrel with any body and as you have seen I have consistently tried to focus on helping out. I do not need to take insults and namecalling from anyone, especially as my answers are not at all personal but general. Maybe you also should have a look at my reply to GM at the women's health posting and then you amy see what is my intention. I agree that personal attacks and abusive language are not to be vented in these pages and as far as I know I have refrained form that. Or do you think that it is in anyway ungentlemanly to defend one's honour? Is that childish?

I also do not like to walk on eggs

[This message has been edited by Ben Rozendal (edited 10 July 1999).]

There are many here who have stated that they are students. It is for those, more than for the experienced practitioners, that I mention things in this forum. If an experienced practitioner feels the need to answer, I would like it to be constructive, so that the students among us (which for me includes myself, as Homoeopathy is a lifelong study) can gain from the experience. Thus, all you experienced peole, can we have constructive debate for the benefit of all?

Its not your opinions we disagree with. It's the war with another practicioner who disagrees with your opinion that we disagree with. No doubt those multitide of people in your "assembly line" are better off from having seen you. You do the best you can with what you've got. We all do. Please stop the grandstanding. We all deserve to ask our questions and give our opinions. -K

I am not participating in this dis cussion,but only for your knowledge Iam writting this.There are so many Homoeopaths in India ,Who is looking more than 100 cases per day.In my case ,I looked more than 4 lakh case in 15 years.In acute cases we will look only the striking symptoms.In chronic cases also we will look in to the peculier symptoms or striking symptoms of the presenting complaints.If we want to take case in detail,I will give special time before 9am.Usually I got good results with our minute doses.I never mixed medicines ,only give it single and some times altrnate in acute cases.If cure take place in this method with our minute doses it must be surely similimum.If we go on detailed case taking in every case ,disregarding striking and peculier symptoms you will get a poly crest ,as poly crest only have dtailed mentals and patient get partial relief.
I can give details of many cases(epilepsy,goitre,ovarian cysts,skin diseases,polyps)etc cured in this method in minute doses of homoeopathic medicines in necessorry repititioin.Any way we only want to cure patients in a harmless way and with minute doses I think.

ToKaren, what you were saying is right. I only gave my experience and get abused. so what can I do? I am interested in constructive discussion only, so i will refrain from further answering to such stuff.

Too Pannakkal, so you know exactly what I mean and yes, my teacher taught me the same way as you describe. I gave more time in the later afternoon in succh cases. I am still grateful for that experience and wish often that my teacher had lived longer than the mere 1 1/2 years I was with him. He was wonderful. later in Vrindavan I was given the opportunity again and actually I hope to retire there and do the same in about 3 - 5 years. Thanks for your understanding. 4 lakh in 15 years is incredible, that is 4 times the amount I saw. You must know your remedies very well by now. All respect for such work.

Jon, I like this topic to be closed. Is that possible?