Sir,

I want to learn a very serious point on homeopathy. Yesterday my lady teacher was telling us about some remedies.

She said

<blockquote>quote:</font><hr>[When well selected remedy fail to give any response on the patient then give Bacil, Thuja and so on.<hr></blockquote>

My question to all my happy members

How could it be possible to take result from a unselected remedy thuja, bacil and others when selected remedy similimum did not produced required result.

When a well selected remedy is working then how an unselected remedy will work

Sir, I am waiting for

This time I will stay silent, since I am neither Gentleman nor Sir, and do not wish to get into further trouble. :razz:

Why don't you ask HER (the teacher) and let us know?

[ 08 November 2001: Message edited by: Kescah ]</p>

__________________
Kescah

Are you sure your teatcher is teaching homeopathy?
Sound rather allopathic to me.
Maybe she is into cartoonhomeopathy, of which I have no clue.
Never mind, be easy and happy and keep at it.

hans Weitbrecht
cure by symptom similarity!

__________________
cure by symptom similarity!<br /><a href="http://www.Boger-Boenninghausen.com/" target="_blank">www.Boger-Boenninghausen.com/</a>

She means give the underlying nosode to open up a layer!! That's provided you know for certain what it is and I think you have a few more years training before you will be able to do that!!

__________________
RSHom - Registered Homeopath

Dr. Cartoon,

Some peoples have made monoply for backing up to each other. They will not respond to your very serious question.

Secondly they will not believe upon you.

Thirdly They easily become bored on serious questions. If you watch their threads. You will never find serious discussion with one another. They have private email contacts.

__________________
Hafeez
Forum Pk

To all,

My answer is

The well selected remedy was actually wrongly selected and hence called unselected, so how an unselected remedy will work?

May be Scrichman have some words for this thread. As I have seen some where in the past. Where she mentioned that when a well selected remedy may not work then give carcinosin. :razz:

[ 10 November 2001: Message edited by: DR.MAS ]</p>

__________________
Hafeez
Forum Pk

And Carsinosin is a nosode!!

__________________
RSHom - Registered Homeopath

Dr. Cartoon.

I can't believe that you are only cartoon by putting this wonderful question.

I am convinced with the remarks given by drmas and ricky. Obviously if a well selected remedy is not working then surly it was wrongly selected.

In our body there are several layers of hurdles in the way of cure and we have to remove those layers with the help of atomic war heads. After long experiences of great homeopaths, they compiled data of those remedies which can produced some reaction in the body, irrespective of symptoms and disease which the patient has. These remedies are our last weapon on patient.

__________________
<b>Love rules without rules.<br />Love rules his kingdom without a sword.<br />Love is like scarlet fever -- one has to go through it and get it over. <br />Where there is love, there is peace. <br />Love is not obedience </b>

Jshah,

But thuja is not nosode.

Hi Dr.MAS,

I don't think I would have said to give Carc when a well selected remedy didn't work. I think of Carc when a case has elements of several different remedies, but doesn't quite fit any of them; and there is a family history of cancer, diabetes and/or heart disease. Plus there have to be some of the specific Carc rubrics in the case.

If a case is stuck, well selected remedies are not working and a particular miasm seems clear, then I would give a nosode. But I actually don't do that very often - I don't feel that I recognize the miasms that easily to be able to easily do that. I'm more likely to look at therir history to find something that is hindering the case - an illness wrongly treated or vaccines, etc.

Maybe someone else can remember who mentioned Carc for stuck cases.

Shirley Reischman

__________________
Shirley Reischman