how long Anthracinum is benificial for Anthrax. Probably it has good curative role preventive!

__________________
Dr.P.K.Sinha

hallo Pksingha
Where is the proving of Anthracinum?
we don't treat by diseasenames, don't we (as homeopaths) or remedy names??

hans weitbrecht
cure by symptom similarity!

__________________
cure by symptom similarity!<br /><a href="http://www.Boger-Boenninghausen.com/" target="_blank">www.Boger-Boenninghausen.com/</a>

hello hens
i am astonised as a hom eopath you are not known to the medicine any how you can find nearly in all books with little effort
every homeopath knows the mode and method of selection of the remedy but you might be knowing numbers of medicines are clinically proved , having less signs and symptoms but very much effective
sometimes treating to aetiology or key notes is also a method fo prescibing
in one sided disease you will find less or no symptom only signs and your obsrvations
defination of a physician is not only to find symptom similimum only he must should be armed with all knowledges about diagnosis prognosis case taking ,medicine, pathology etc
hope this will guide you to learn more about homeopathy
with
regards

__________________
Dr.P.K.Sinha

My experience has been, with diseases like Scabies(Psor), Gonorrhoea (Med), Measles(Morb), Cancer(Carc), that the nosode rarely cures the acute condition. It is the similar remedy that helps, based on the unique symptoms of the patient, not the symptoms of the disease that allows us to cure. Anthracinum might cure certain patients with the disease if the symptoms matched, but would not cure all patients just because they have the (named) disease.

The nosodes are much more useful in helping those people whose health has been badly affected by the presence of the disease in their past, either in themselves or in their ancestry, but even then it is not reliable.

I believe Hans was saying the Law of Similars should not be disregarded whenever a serious illness pops up, but we should always be guided by the patients individual reaction, or the epidemic picture, in choosing remedies.

Really, if we are looking at protecting our patients (and the hysteria has reached Australia now too), we should be reinforcing our basic rules of treatment, rather than fanning the fires of fear sweeping the world. It would be more appropriate for us to look at remedies for this panic, than start prescribing, or even suggesting, Anthracinum.

Anthracinum seems to have been used clinically, rather than by proving. It was used as a nosode by a vetinary surgeon in the days of Hahnemann, whose name was Lux, I think. Its clinical picture has been described by Jeff Baker, presented at a conference in 1990. Vermeulen has the remedy in his Synoptic Materia Medica vol II.

__________________
David Kempson.<br />Dip.Homoeopathic Medicine.<br />Lecturer Australian College of Natural Therapies (Brisbane Campus)<br />Member AHA, AROH, HMA<br />Member Australian Homoeopathic Association. Member#0442.

*bump* for punkin38

__________________
Regards,<br /><b>Simone H</b><br /><br /><i>Aude Sapere</i><br /><br />"Never be a passive listener or learner" ~ Christian Gottfried Hahnemann

Hallo to all
If Anthracinum has not been proven, then it needs to.
volunteers please !
Ps.: still looking for Carcinosum provers to carry out a full Hahnemannian proving.

Hans Weitbrecht
Cure by symptom similarity!

__________________
cure by symptom similarity!<br /><a href="http://www.Boger-Boenninghausen.com/" target="_blank">www.Boger-Boenninghausen.com/</a>

Han, Pksinha and Davidjk,

Time will come, when all my research / opinion will be accepted. It is very difficult to accept new ideas and thoughts.

There is no rule in homeopathy for prescription are very well appreciated by many members on this board through private email directly and not via this BB board.

I have already mentioned that through disease you can prescribe remedies. This all based on clinical experience. If you could diagnose the disease I can assure you that your prescribed remedy will get 100 % result. I strongly recommend to every one that to prescribe remedies on disease. Because certain remedies are found very effective against various diseases. These observations are based on long clinical trials. You can see that Practice of Homeopathic Medicine books are more popular than repertories. The reason is that you can easily select remedies keeping in view of the symptoms of the diseases. We cannot deny the results of cure (I am using for teaching just like Hahnemann used disease for teaching purpose only) based on practice of medicine over disease concept.

That’s I proved in my topic there is no rule in homeopathy for prescription. Hans at last will accept different ways of prescriptions. People like Hans, who believes upon old and bogus thoughts are the great hurdles in the progress of homoeopathy. They have lessons for others but himself don’t want to learn.

<blockquote>quote:</font><hr>The proving of Cinchona bark by Hahnemann on himself brought out similarity of symptoms to AGUE FEVER. Hahnemann felt the chill, fever, perspiration followed by apyrexia the very common symptoms to AGUE FEVER. Hence he concluded that the remedy which in its provings produces similar symptoms of a disease is the specific homeopathic remedy because it acts through the vital force and produces a similar disease. Some of the symptoms which were not resembling to any disease at that time. He suggested that for those symptoms which are not similar to any disease but found during proving should be treated on the basis of symptoms only and those which are similar to some disease like AGUE FEVER should be given on disease name.<hr></blockquote>

Further provings of drugs showed a number of drugs having specifics homeopathic similarity to other diseases i.e.

Here are some specifics found after so many clinical trials. Enjoy reading.

Bell = Scarlet Fever
Puls = Measles
Ant tart = Chicken pox
Dros = Whooping Cough
Eup perf = Dengue Fever
Ars alb = Influenza
Merc cyan =Diphtheria
Vert alb = Asiatic Cholera
Crot hori = Yellow Fever
Ars iod = Pulmonary Tuberculosis
Kali iod = Secondary Syphilis
Thuja = Sycosis
Nit acid = Sycosis

__________________
Hafeez
Forum Pk

Dr.Mas
i agrre with your feelings with approach of treatment up to some extent if you recall my first posting"culture and sensitivity with homeo medicine "posted about one year back ,you will find how I have tried to co relate sign and symptoms of pt. with pathological provings
since I was student alwayays trying to find the mechanism of action of medicine , because I joined the ciurse leaving M.B.B.S .i was not truly in mood to accept the philosophy . because as a science graduate I was always seeking the way where ,how why the smll dose act finally I came to conclusion homeopathic medicines are meant for homeopathy pts.and hahnemann's rule can only cure such pts.but besides the curable diseases ther are any one sided or partial pictre presenting diseases wher no rule provide its physicians skill how he tackles
thanks further i will present my views on getting time I appreciate your views a healthy discussion adds new kowledge
regards

__________________
Dr.P.K.Sinha

Dr. Pk Sinha,

Thanks for your remarks. Don't take this post as back up service. I don't need any kind of help from any side. I am not interested in making friends so that they could back me up in my posts. All thsese peoples have private emails contacts. They support to each other, whether they are right or wrong.

I did read your post at that time. All these people supported you and greatly appreciated you on your work. I encourage you to please continue your work.

Hans at that time was not registered. He needs some kind of regular study in the college. I will recommend him to do something in pharmacy or chemistry.

What about you general health. I am worry about your wife. How is she. Is she fully recovered now from burnt. Pay my SALAM to her.

Don't you ever think that I nevered entered in my life to any forum where patient's serious discussion is going on. The reason is fairly clear. I have no objection for any perscriptions. I want to eradicate bogus thoughts which are hurdles in way of homeopathic progress.

Now I decided to send private messages to every member. Introduced my self. The mission which i want to accomplish. So for no body knows about me.

I don't require any help from any side. I have the ability to do myself.

Believe me so for my all threads all proved at the end. You have the opinion to disagree.