Dr Bhatia, I complement you on your clear, robust and full explanation which I enjoyed for all those reasons.

Dr. Ghazi!

I will talk you in your native language MAKRANI. Then you can easily understand.

"ARAY TUM TU APNA YAAR AAY. PHIR TUM INKA SAATH KEEOU DITA NEE. MAY TU INKO TUNG KUR RAH HOON. TUM KO TU APAN KA SAATH DINA CHAHAYAY

NAI ARAY HAN ARAY WAH ARAY"

I can make it more simple

I find the phrase "Get yourself an english tutor" quite irrelevant but very interesting because there are several poorly written sentences apart from a glaring grammatical mistake in the "rejoinder" of Dr. Bhatia. Now should I say that Dr. Bhatia too needs a tutor for English?

------------------
Ghazi

Ghazi I think Dr Bhatia was just exasperated at the questionner's lack of comprehension of The Organon, and suspected that the problem might be linguistic in origin.

Dr. Mas and Dr. Ghazi,
I am sorry to see that people like U exist on this bb. The theif in U has left a trail. Incidentally, I also know Makrani and I am presenting the translation of the text U have published in your native language for everyone's disposel.

Dr. Ghazi!
I will talk you in your native language MAKRANI. Then you can easily understand.

"Oh U are a friend(because belonging to same cast and country I suppose). Then why are U favouring these people. I am just trying to annoy these people. U should be on my side

Oh No Oh Yes Oh Woh"

Dr. Mas, If U have any shame left. Please donot post on this bb.



------------------
GOD grant me the SERENITY to accept the things I cannot change, The COURAGE to change the things I can, And the WISDOM to know the Difference.

It looks as if Dr. MAS has very little credibility left here. Thank you, Dr. Bhatia, for the translation. Exclusivity should have no place on this BB.

[This message has been edited by nrg grl (edited 13 February 2001).]

What Dr. MAS has done is sad and perturbing.
But what Dr. Bhatia has done by bracketing me with Dr. MAS is shocking. I think, Dr. Bhatia is a conscientious person and would like to take back his words.

The language used by DR. MAS is URDU, not MAKRANI. MAKRANI IS A DIALECT OF BALUCHI LANGUAGE SPOKEN IN a few towns of Pakistan.


------------------
Ghazi

Dr. Gahzi,
Form your posts I know that U r a sincere person. But after Dr. Mas's invitation to join hands, U actually seemed to have joined hands by trying to find typographical errors in my post. So I had no option to bracket U together. And I do not regret that. The post was addressed to both of U, but the strong words were primarily meant for mas as it was he who left the trail. And in the last I have only requested Mas to refrain from making posts here. Any person, U or anyone else, interested in healthy discussions, is always welcome in this community.

I do not want to indulge in wanton arguments but what you say is too short of what I expected of you. My allusion to a glaring GRAMMATICAL MISTAKE (and several poorly written sentences) was meant to discourage the practice of ridiculing those with poor knowledge of English as, given the sensitivity of the educated population of South-east Asian region about their "proficiency in English", such a trend could create a sense of inferiority complex, thus keeping away many a bright homoeopath from participation in discussions simply for their inability to write correct English. It should not have been taken as taking sides with anybody.

------------------
Ghazi

[This message has been edited by Ghazi (edited 14 February 2001).]

Dr. Ghazi,
Anna had very aptly described the reason behind that comment about english tutor. It was not about the language only, but also about the comprehension of a written text.
And I donot have the time to think about creating perfect sentences while I make posts. In essence the thoughts should go across. And I never claimed to have a degree in english honours. Its about basic comprehension.

And U should not be expecting any more. Reason being, U were the first person to have read dr. mas's post and if U really felt it perturbing(as U do now) than U should have condemned it then and there. But U mooted him silently and what U do instead is find language related mistakesof mine(And ignore the big thought related mistakeof dr. mas). So how do U expect more?? Answer me, Why didn't U busted dr. Mas yourself after reading his post???? I am sure U don't have a convincing answer.