TimOkay,

Now you will realized that why I asked you in my first post (potentization thread) about potentization concept. Few peoples are saying the medicine is immaterial nature and few are saying the medicine is purely material in nature. If the medicine is immaterial then which thing you are potentizing. Have homeopaths started potentizing soul or spiritual power? Your references also proves it controversial. I hope you have yourself read them in detail.

I again say homeopathic medicine is purely materialistic in nature. These medicines have very sound pathological effects in the body. After the administration of the medicine, speedy chemical changes were seen and observed in the body. These changes were further tested and verified in the lab. These changes were varied time to time with the change of medicine type and potency. This also proves that homeopathic medicines have matter inside which bring exact chemical product just like when we add sodium and chlorine and always get Natrium Muriticum.

Foolish and Non-sense homeopaths can never understand that during proving those were the only chemicals of the crude substance which brought further chemical changes in the body with the chemicals present inside the body and symptoms were appeared. These symptoms noted FOR the medicine in materia medica.

Quinine was given in the crude form (matter) which brought chemical changes inside and outside the body after the reaction between quinine and chemical already present inside the body, as result we noted symptoms in the “HEALTHY” person, later on the same medicine in minute quantity (still in mater form) was given which again brought chemical changes with the reaction of chemical present inside the “PATIENT’s” body and patient has been cured.

In the Hahnemannian time he never used high potencies like cm or dm…. to whom twaddle homeopaths are calling immaterial medicine jus due to the scientific test not available to detect starting material. This is the problem of the science and not ours. So in lieu we can’t say the medicine which was started from matter later on converted to spiritual non material substance. This is rubbish talk, which do not deserve to educated personalities? This sure try to give discredit to homeopathy.

Hahnemann mostly used 3x, 6x, 12c and 18 etc Was he not doing homeopathy? These medicines were all containing matters. He never said the medicine is immaterial in nature. If the medicine is spiritual in nature and no matter is inside then there is no need of proving the crude medicine and requirements of 3000 starting materials.