Joes article was discussed earlier also.I agree method is not truly classical .But I did use same Arnica in different condition in Joes way much before reading Joes cases .WONDERFUL RESULTS. Arnica after
tooth extraction hardly 2-4 doses in 30 potency avoided lot of pain killers and anibiotics .Is it not waste of time in going through eloborate case taking etc in simple condition?
Daily dose of Arnica 6th potency in Cardiac patient made his life comfortable which was not possible with much lot of medicines by Cardiologist .Like many cases I also can quote.
I agree classical way of prescription is always desirable but in many conditions ,rather in incurable conditions and if we have to help patient along with allopathic medicine and where palliation is only alternative ,methods other than classical also are valuable .
I always try to follow classical method in most of curable cases.It is my experience that Classical method is not always effective .
Persons who cry foul with other methods ,in my openion are not much clinically oriented . Patient is more important than method .What ever U do in intrest of patient is OK

Ramachandra,
Hyderabad,INDIA