OK, so I am supposed to be impressed. But when I read his bio, he was trained through CHED by Boiron, which is a clinical prescribers type course (French method). has it's merits, but for clinical prescribing, not classical prescribing. Then, he has written a book "Easy Homeopathy" - the 7 remedies for each ailment. (http://www.homeopathynewyork.com/bio.html)

Yeah, been there, done that. He may be a good classical prescriber, but nothing in his bio, including the Herscu training (NESH) would convince me yet. So, like I said, it's just his opinion. Clinical prescribing, french method stuff won't deal with deeper issues, unless by chance you hit the simillimum, and we shouldn't rely on chance.

Now, how about replying to my post on Vithoulkas?

Paul

----- Original Message -----
From: healthyinfo6 (AT) aol (DOT) com
To: pb000014 (AT) pixie (DOT) co.za ; homeopathy (AT) homeolist (DOT) com
Sent: Wednesday, March 19, 2008 1:08 AM
Subject: Re: Vithoulkas trained homeopath says genetic illness incurable!


Paul,

Edward Shalts, MD DHt, the homeopathic doctor who stated that genetic illness is incurable, will be speaking at the NCH conference in April. Since the NCH unofficially "represents" homeopathy in the USA, they must have thought highly enough of Dr. Shalts and his knowledge of classical homeopathy to invite him to speak. He's on the same bill as Andre Saine and Jeremy Sherr! How much more classical can you get???

Of course, Andre Saine NOT using LM potencies and disputing the validity of the Organon 6th edition negates a proven component of classical homeopathy but hasn't prevented him from speaking or teaching at NCH. Whether this advances homeopathy into Century 21 is another story. As for Jeremy Sherr, not sure how much he may divulge from The Founder.

http://nationalcenterforhomeopathy.o...HConfBro08.pdf

Obviously, Dr. Shalts must know something that many here can't seem to admit!

Susan

------------------------------------------------------------------------

> Here's a highly regarded Vithoulkas trained homeopath, a diplomate of
homeopathy, EDWARD SHALTS, M.D., D.Ht.,?who has the medical and homeopathic
knowledge to admit that classical homeopathy can not cure genetically
predetermined illnesses, like diabetes, breast cancer, Alzheimers,
>Parkinsons, etc.?

How come I should be impressed that he is "Vithoulkas trained". We tend to
laud everything Vithoulkas says , does and touches as gospel. He is (IMO)
losing the plot. Actually he lost it long ago. His theory on mechanism of
action and vital force is in direct contradiction of hahnemann,, he does not
know his Organon (although he would no doubt dispute this), he trashes
Sankaran, and now he says remedy action is like placebo. Exactly what the
allopaths would love to hear. They can now say homeopathy is placebo and the
great Vithoulkas said it, so we aren't allowed to disagree. Vithoulkas is
doing a lot of harm to homeopathy and needs to get off his
pedestal/mountain.

I do not know Edward Shalts; i do not know any positive contribution he has
made to the SCIENCE of homeopathy , so the above is just his opinion. All
this is based on the assumption that he his "descended from the great
master"

Not for me thank you, and I suggest anyone who disagrees with me first
really look at Vithoulkas's statements and compare them to Hahnemann.
Unfortunately a lot of homeopaths have been to Vithoulkas and simpky follow
his teachings (Margaret Roy etc.) and so our schools regurgitate Vithoulkas
without really studying Organon , as an UNPREJUDICED OBSERVER.

Paul



> Only the non-medically trained, non-compassionate classical homeopath
would tell patients to go off allopathic drugs that save lives while falsely
attempting to cure conditions that ARE NOT CURABLE!
>
> Enough with the classical homeopathic "magic tricks".
>
> "We also need to remember that certain conditions (genetically
predetermined illnesses, for example) and late stages of chronic diseases
are irreversible. There is no magic trick that would allow curing a person
with the end-stage chronic illness. In situations like that palliation (a
reduction of severity of symptoms) is the goal of treatment. "
>
> http://www.homeopathynewyork.com/benefit.html
>
>



------------------------------------------------------------------------------


No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG.
Version: 0.0.518 / Virus Database: 269.21.7/1328 - Release Date: 2008/03/13 11:31 AM