30th November 2004, 10:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Re: [Minutus] Will Taylor post/sycosis 2 - Eratta
Hi David,
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by David Little
I am a typographical mistake in this part of my post.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by David Little
The contested passage dealing with heredity is the second half of the footnote to §284. The first half §284 is in the handwriting of Hahnemann were he speaks of transmitting psora through the breast milk if it has not been already passed "by inheritance from the mother".
|
No - this is not written in Hahnemann's handwriting but in "Kanzleischrift". By someone unknown.
Schmidt says about it:
The portions written in Kanzleischrift again not rarely contain additional inserts or changes in Hahnemann's own handwriting. Obviously they are dictations, which were revised by H. himself and therefore - at least in those cases - can be considered authentic. Portions in this script that do not contain additions by Hahnemann for the most part are merely new versions of text also existent in Hahnemann's handwriting or purely corrections of syntactic matters. The only exception which is relevant as to the content is that of the footnote to aphor 284, which is in "Kanzleischrift" and states that
"psora could also be inheritable", which, however, is in concordance with a remark in Hahnemann's own handwriting (footnote to aphor 78)
(Schmidt ...., 1999 edition, page XVII)
As to the rest - see my other post.
Regards
Luise
Last edited by jonh; 1st December 2004 at 06:31 PM.
|