I was not interested to take this thread further But after reading Jvman last post. I want to clarify my position. This post of mine is directed to my two honourable members. Who came here as justice.
Barb & Lisa,
I did not give any rude remarks. However, If you feel that I was wrong. Then I am ready to ask for apology from her. But before asking, I would like to ask you to clarify to me what I did wrong.
Asid asked a question
“is there any cure for alopecia areata in homeopathy for a 4 year old?”.
I really don’t know who is that person. I feel that we should not discourage to any body for asking any question on the board regarding their problem in health. Asid asked the question. I don’t know whether he/she is familiar with homeopathic rules or not. My respectable members Jvolkman responded very well and gave him/her satisfactory answer according to her judgment / view. I certainly have no objection what so ever against her on her reply to Asid. As she was not a homeopath, hence her answer was according to her was right. You can read the above mentioned posts that I did not object on her opinion. I generally don’t like to interrupt in health care problems of members who used to come on this BB and never remain interested in prescribing. As I feel that homeopath will never stand at one point as for as prescription is concerned. They will always object on other prescription and try to confuse the patient. That is why I never gave any suggestion on other forums like child & woman health, skin and pet forum. I feel that I don’t have to interrupt. I am a silent reader in those forums. In general discussion forum. When I came and read that post. I gave my opinion according to my thinking and point of view. I did not say “Jvolkman opinion is a non sense approach”. I am a professional homeopath in Pakistan. I have done 4 year regular course of DHMS from Recognized institution of Government Pakistan. Secondly BHMS from recognized university of Pakistan beside one year regular course of DHMCS. I am registered homeopath under Ministry of Health government of Pakistan bearing license number 56209. So I responded according to my own believe and sense.
I replied the following simple answer with out objection.
Bacil 200 per week empty stomach
Acid Flour 30 tds daily for fifteen days
100 % result
My question is to you.
1. What I did wrong in my first post? When Asid asked a simple question and I responded with simple answer.
My respectable member Jvolkman came after my post and shouted with these words.
No "homeopath" worth a tinker's dam would prescribe based on a 14 word sentence, nor arbitrarily prescribe
two different remedies without assessing the effect of the first prescribed. This is allopathy disguised as homeopathy, and
dangerous nonsense.
My question is to you.
2. In which direction s/he (JVolkman) routed her post? (For your convenience, I marked some words in bold)
3. Were not her remarks …………... ruuuuuuude?
4. Do you agree with her on calling DANGEROUS NONSENSE to me or any other member?
5. When I did not interrupt her on her reply to Asid? Then why she did interrupt between a patient (Asid) and homeopath (Dr.MAS)?
6. Where you (Barb) were when she posted above paragraph. Why did you not halt her?
Although, I tried my best to satisfy layman members on this board, who used to come for getting knowledge, by giving explanation from prominent homeopaths but I think, this type of interruption create a bad impression among the general public about homeopathy and homeopaths. They will definitely say that one is suggesting remedies for patient ailment with great care and profession ethics and other is calling him/her DANGEROUS NON SENSE. Secondly, I just advised to her that she should develop professional ethics and don’t create bewilderment and misunderstanding between a doctor and a patient. Because a doctors knows better what is wrong and what is right in his/her opinion. A non qualified person has no right to disrupt any qualified doctor’s opinion and calling him/her non sense.
Although, I am not curious to read your answers because I know that you will not justify your answers. You are just backing up her for her off beam attitude. But will be happy to read according to given sequence from you after 21st April 2002. I have to leave for Lahore.
O.K. You given your verdict that she was right in her attitude against me on this thread. (I feel in advance that I can’t get impartiality from you)
O.K. I accept your decision. I ask for forgiveness to Jvolkman. I know she will forgive me on my innocent approach, as she is very kind. Every body hate me. No body wants to talk to me. Is there no place for me on this board. My example is of that child to whom no body wants to play squash and he plays alone with the court wall. Look at the tears in my eyes……