Dr Leela - has Sankaran done a whole new series of provings on Silica, or are his descriptions derived from observations of his cases?

I've been reading the lyghtforce list, and I didn't want to have that sort of somewhat grouchy discussion - I thought it might be easier to discuss these new ideas within the framework of a single, well-known remedy.

Does Scholten's idea of anger and father/family issues come through as a core symptom for your Silica cases? I can, from what little I know as a student, understand Sankaran's picture - it relates well to the traditional. But the Scholten one I have trouble with, not because I think he's making it up, but because I can't see where he got those ideas from, I suppose.

[ 19 January 2002: Message edited by: felix ]</p>