Thread: Rubric help
View Single Post
  #9 (permalink)  
Old 14th February 2001, 05:19 PM
Divina's Avatar
Divina Divina is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: southern ontario, canada
Posts: 1,310
Divina is an unknown quantity at this point
Post

MIND, DELUSIONS, imaginations; Trapped, he is: haliae-lc, lac-eq2, lap-c-b
(Complete Repertory).

There it is. Solid, SCIENTIFIC data of a mental emotional state produced by these 3 substances under rigidly controlled circumstances--what we call a proving.

No speculation at all. No "amateur" psychoanalysis required. Homeopaths are taught very well to know the difference between psychoanalysis and homeopathic consultation. Speculation is the weakness in homeopathic philosophy and practice. Psychoanalysts speculate: homeopaths gather and analyze facts.

If you don't know why your patient feels trapped, consider that they must have given some thought about their situation to formulate such a description about it. Honour their expression of themselves: ASK what it is about their situation which makes them feel this way, and keep asking for clarification until the patient has made you fully understand why they feel this way--what is at the core of their expression. Then you will have your answer--clear, concise, real--not speculative.

If, however, all you have to go on is this stated belief, don't worry--you don't have to speculate there, either. In this case, the delusion (and it is a delusion, as we can see--she feels trapped, but she really is not trapped) is produced by these listed substances. It appears in the repertory.

I would say that this symptom is far more important and revealing than the physical particulars. That is why the mental/emotional symptoms are always hierarchicalized as the most important symptoms in the case--and also the reason why, when a remedy is chosen to address the m/e state, the physicals (even if they are not part of the remedy's "symptom picture") just take care of themselves. Whereas this seldom holds true "in reverse".

Divina
Reply With Quote