Dear Dr. Mas,
Thanks for making an individual post for me.
Firts U answer a question..
What do U mean by the word "COMBINATION"???
Now read my replies...
1. First of all there is no medicine which is EXACTLY(100%) similar to any one person. If that had been the case one medicine would have worked on just one person and we would have to prove 6 billion medicines for the humanity because no two persons are all alike. So, since the time of Hahnemann, everyone(including Hahnemann) has prescribed the "MOST SIMILAR"(and not exactly similar) remedy AVAILABLE in the chest.
2. so there is no doubt that I will not send the patient U have mentioned home, but would prescribe the most similar remedy that I can find or I have. BUT HOW DOES AN IMPERFECTLY SIMILAR REMEDY CAN BE CALLED A "COMBINATION" IS BEYOND MY COMPREHENSION. please enligten us.
3. In your first post what U have mentioned is that once a medicine has partially removed the symptoms, whether to give the next best med found in original analysis or to take the case afresh and re-repertorize. Well! What's the point in this question, I can't make out. It has always been a standard to take the case afresh when symptoms change or are parially removed by one med. And there is nothing wrong in using a "series of medicines" if a med similar enough or deep enough to remove all the complaints can not be found. BUT STILL IN THIS CASE TOO EACH MED IS GIVEN SINGELY AT A TIME. SO HOW IT BECOMES A "COMBINATION" IS BEYOND MY COMPREHENSION.
3 U have said "Although you himself has the habit of prescribing other (near to similar) remedies when you did not find any exact similar remedy according to patient."
"I have seen many practioner, when they do practice, they have a different point of view and when they were asked to talk on homoeo philosophy or rules and regulations, they have different point of view."
PLEASE DON'T BE SO COURAGEOUS TO TALK ABOUT MY PRACTISE WHEN U DON'T EVEN KNOW ME OR THE WAY I PRACTISE. I practise what I preach.
4. Hahnemann has never advocated the use of combinations(read 272). U seem to be very confused regarding the interpretation of Hahnemann's text and U are doing the same to others. Get yourself an english tutor or buy the urdu edition of organon.
5. And lastly, I did not "Used to" add that quotation. I still do, whenever I feel like it. And it's not a quotation, it's a prayer.
------------------
GOD grant me the SERENITY to accept the things I cannot change, The COURAGE to change the things I can, And the WISDOM to know the Difference.
|